9 min. read

The Best Ice Cream Sandwich for 2023

The perfect treat for a sweet tooth to help you cool off in warm weather

Everyone loves ice cream. And who doesn’t love cookies? Just imagine the taste of them together! Anyone who enjoys the creamy flavor of ice cream and the crunch of cookies will love ice cream sandwiches.

With plenty of flavors to choose from, ice cream sandwiches can be enjoyed as a dessert after dinner, next to the poolside on a hot summer day, or even as a movie snack on a cold night in! This sweet and creamy sandwich has been around since the early 1900s, and it is still popular today with even more delectable and inventive flavors.

We’ve chosen the best ice cream sandwiches, from rich vanilla ice cream to tender yet crunchy wafer biscuits, to help you make an easier and more economical purchase.

How We Picked

  • Taste

    For a snack that looks this good, it needs to taste good too! When purchasing Ice Cream Sandwiches, aim for a creamy ice cream taste and soft cookies/wafers for the perfect tasting sandwich.

  • Quantity

    Most ice cream sandwiches are served in four, six, or twelve packs. However, there are single packs. Purchasing a box of ice cream sandwiches will depend on how many people you want to serve.

  • Quality of Ingredients

    Ice cream sandwiches contain a few allergens. Always look out for the ingredients list to see if this product is good for your health.

  • Price

    We’ve selected only the best and most-loved brands that offer good value (and ice cream sandwiches) for your money.

Our Top Picks

Best Pick

Favorite Day Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches

You won’t be able to get enough of these creamy vanilla ice cream sandwiches!

The Favorite Day Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches are by far our best pick, and apparently, everyone else's too! With 12 per box, these sweet sandwiches with a creamy vanilla taste are the perfect option if you're hosting a party, a dinner with family or friends, or if you’re just looking to store a box in the freezer to last you for the rest of the summer holiday.

Buy Now

The best classic vanilla ice cream sandwiches.

Runner Up

So Delicious Vanilla Bean Coconut Milk Sandwiches

These dairy-free Vanilla Bean ice cream sandwiches are every coconut lover's favorite!

The So Delicious Vanilla Bean Coconut Milk ice cream sandwiches live up to their brand name - so delicious!! With eight servings per box, these smooth and dairy-free ice cream sandwiches are guaranteed to become your favorite, whether you’re vegan or non-vegan. It has the perfect balance between the vanilla and coconut flavors and combines perfectly with the delicious chocolate taste of the wafers.

Buy Now

Delicious dairy-free and coconut-infused vanilla ice cream sandwiches.

Most cost-effective

M&M’s Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

Spoil the kids at the next birthday party with these colorful and delicious ice cream sandwiches!

The taste of these M&M’s Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches will have you finishing the entire box in less than a week! This classic vanilla ice cream is sandwiched between two crunchy M&M sugar cookies — every kid’s dream! Listed under our most cost-effective ice cream sandwich, this 24-pack is perfect for kids' parties.

Buy Now for $69.99 ($2.92 / Count)

The most colorful, fun, and delicious ice cream sandwich!

Almost made the cut

Skinny Cow Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches

The best low-fat ice cream on the market!

The Skinny Cow Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches are made with Skinny Cow’s low-fat ice cream and 100% cocoa! With six servings per box, these ice cream sandwiches are guaranteed to satisfy your sweet cravings without making those who are following a strict diet feel guilty about satisfying their all-time snack fetish - ice cream!

Buy Now

Low-fat ice cream at its best!

Everything We Recommend

Best Pick

Favorite Day Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches

You won’t be able to get enough of these creamy vanilla ice cream sandwiches!

Buy Now

Runner Up

So Delicious Vanilla Bean Coconut Milk Sandwiches

These dairy-free Vanilla Bean ice cream sandwiches are every coconut lover's favorite!

Buy Now

Most cost-effective

M&M’s Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

Spoil the kids at the next birthday party with these colorful and delicious ice cream sandwiches!

$69.99 ($2.92 / Count)

Buy Now

Almost made the cut

Skinny Cow Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches

The best low-fat ice cream on the market!

Buy Now

Who This Is For

The products advertised here are for people of all ages looking for the best ice cream sandwiches on the market. Whether you’re looking to serve them at a kid’s party, a backyard barbeque with the family, or simply to store them in your freezer for whenever your ice cream craving kicks in, these ice cream sandwiches are delicious for any occasion!
Are ice cream sandwiches healthy?
Indulging in too many ice cream sandwiches daily can be quite unhealthy, so it’s best to eat them in moderate amounts. In addition, different ice cream sandwich brands use different ingredients — some have low-fat milk, are dairy-free, have less sugar, and have fewer calories. As much as we all love the sweet creaminess of ice cream, it’s best to check the ingredients if you’re allergic to anything or if you’re a little conscious about what you consume.
How long can they be kept in the freezer?
Ice cream sandwiches can be kept in the freezer for as long as three months.

Why You Should Trust Us

Well, we appreciate the taste of a delicious ice cream sandwich, and we know that there’s nothing worse than biting into one that’s hard, too messy, and tastes like cardboard! That’s why we listed the best brands suited to every person’s needs and tastes, and, of course, brands that are well worth your money.

How We Picked

When we selected the tastes and flavors of the ice cream sandwiches listed here, we aimed to stick with a classic vanilla ice cream and chocolate wafers, as this is a flavor combination many people grew up loving when it came to ice cream sandwiches. For variety, we selected different diet options and ingredients, such as dairy-free or low-fat ice cream, and something fun and colorful for the kids!
We’ve also listed ice cream sandwiches with different quantities at suitable prices — between six, eight, 12, and 24 — so that you can choose the right quantity of sandwiches to suit your needs.

Our Picks For You

Best Pick - Favorite Day Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches

Best Pick

Favorite Day Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches

You won’t be able to get enough of these creamy vanilla ice cream sandwiches!

The Favorite Day Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches are by far our best pick, and apparently, everyone else's too! With 12 per box, these sweet sandwiches with a creamy vanilla taste are the perfect option if you're hosting a party, a dinner with family or friends, or if you’re just looking to store a box in the freezer to last you for the rest of the summer holiday.

Buy Now

Who it is for

The Favorite Day Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches are for anyone looking for a classic vanilla and chocolate wafer-tasting ice cream sandwich. It’s also great for those looking to stock up on these cold, creamy sandwiches for the hot summer holiday or a quick sharing dessert for the whole family!

Why it is great

What makes this brand so great is the fact that each box is stacked with 12 sandwiches, making it ideal for sharing or stocking in the freezer for a summer vacation away. They are sold at an affordable price too. The ice cream has the sweet vanilla taste we all crave when we think of ice cream, and the wafers are chocolate flavored, which blends perfectly with the ice cream flavor.

Potential flaws

The wheat, soy, and milk ingredients in the Favorite Day Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches may be harmful to people who must avoid these foods for medical reasons.

Other features

The Favorite Day Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches have artificial flavoring added. The ice cream ingredients include, among other ingredients, milkfat and nonfat milk, high fructose corn syrup, sugar, whey, and less than 2% natural and artificial flavor. The wafers contain bleached wheat flour, sugar, palm oil, corn flour, and 2% cocoa, among other ingredients. These ice cream sandwiches are easy to store in the freezer and ready to eat whenever you crave them. They’re also easy to hold and you can bite into this delicious snack!

Product specifications

12 sandwiches per box
Vanilla ice cream flavor
Chocolate flavored wafers
Contains wheat, soy, and milk

Runner Up - So Delicious Vanilla Bean Coconut Milk Sandwiches

Runner Up

So Delicious Vanilla Bean Coconut Milk Sandwiches

These dairy-free Vanilla Bean ice cream sandwiches are every coconut lover's favorite!

The So Delicious Vanilla Bean Coconut Milk ice cream sandwiches live up to their brand name - so delicious!! With eight servings per box, these smooth and dairy-free ice cream sandwiches are guaranteed to become your favorite, whether you’re vegan or non-vegan. It has the perfect balance between the vanilla and coconut flavors and combines perfectly with the delicious chocolate taste of the wafers.

Buy Now

Who it is for

The So Delicious Dairy Free Vanilla Bean ice cream sandwiches are made with coconut milk, making them every vegan coconut lover’s favorite. This product is also recommended, especially for those who are lactose intolerant.

Why it is great

This ice cream sandwich brand is great for its smooth ice cream texture and soft cookies! With eight servings per box, it's the perfect coconut dessert to carry with you to a picnic to enjoy with your friends, or to simply serve after dinner or a movie night in! The coconut taste blends perfectly with the vanilla ice cream taste and chocolate biscuits. It is not only dairy-free but also lactose-free and soy-free.

Potential flaws

If you're not a fan of coconut, then this ice cream sandwich might not be your best option.

Other features

The ice cream ingredients for this product include, among other things, organic coconut milk, organic cane sugar, organic coconut oil, and vanilla extract. The wafer ingredients include, among other ingredients, wheat flour, cane sugar, palm oil, organic brown rice syrup, caramel color, cocoa, and natural vanilla flavor. This plant-based also has no artificial flavors or colors added, soy, added MSG, or trans fat. They're also the perfect size for an easy hold while eating!

Product specifications

Dairy-free
Lactose and soy-free
Eight sandwiches per box
Vanilla Bean ice cream flavor
Coconut flavor
Chocolate wafers

Most cost-effective - M&M’s Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

Most cost-effective

M&M’s Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

Spoil the kids at the next birthday party with these colorful and delicious ice cream sandwiches!

The taste of these M&M’s Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches will have you finishing the entire box in less than a week! This classic vanilla ice cream is sandwiched between two crunchy M&M sugar cookies — every kid’s dream! Listed under our most cost-effective ice cream sandwich, this 24-pack is perfect for kids' parties.

Buy Now for $69.99 ($2.92 / Count)

Who it is for

The M&M Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich is perfect for the whole family! Advertised here is the box of 24 ice cream sandwiches, which makes it ideal for the next kid's birthday party. It’s colorful, fun, and full of crispy deliciousness!

Why it is great

This sandwich is great for its creamy, sweet vanilla ice cream sandwiched between two M&M cookies! The M&M cookie is quite thin and tender, making the bite quick and delicious as it all melts in your mouth. With the M&M Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich, you’ll be getting the best of three worlds - cookies, ice cream, and crunchy, chocolatey M&Ms!

Potential flaws

This product contains wheat, soy, and milk. It may also contain peanuts and tree nuts.

Other features

The ice cream ingredients for this product contain, among other ingredients, skim milk, sugar, cream, corn syrup, cocoa butter, lactose, and natural and artificial colors. The cookie contains bleached wheat flour, and the M&M candies contain lactose, cocoa butter, sugar, and more. These ice cream sandwiches have the round shape of a thick cookie, making them easy to hold and eat.

Product specifications

24 sandwiches per box
Vanilla ice cream flavor
Sugar cookies with M&M’s
Contains wheat, soy, and milk
Made with reduced-fat ice cream

Almost made the cut - Skinny Cow Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches

Almost made the cut

Skinny Cow Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches

The best low-fat ice cream on the market!

The Skinny Cow Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches are made with Skinny Cow’s low-fat ice cream and 100% cocoa! With six servings per box, these ice cream sandwiches are guaranteed to satisfy your sweet cravings without making those who are following a strict diet feel guilty about satisfying their all-time snack fetish - ice cream!

Buy Now

Who it is for

The Skinny Cow Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches are for those ice cream lovers looking for a healthier option.

Why it is great

The Skinny Cow Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches are made with low-fat ice cream, which makes them great for those following a strict diet. With six servings per box, these ice cream sandwiches are the perfect dessert to serve the whole family after a scrumptious dinner. The vanilla light ice cream has a sweet, velvety taste to it and is sandwiched between two delicious chocolate cookies.

Potential flaws

The Skinny Cow Vanilla Ice Cream contains milk, wheat, and soy ingredients that may be harmful to those who are allergic. A few Skinny Cow Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwich tasters have said that the ice cream does not taste as rich and creamy as full-fat ice cream, which might be a disappointment to some.

Other features

The Skinny Cow light ice cream ingredients include skim milk, corn syrup, sugar, cream, and buttermilk, among other ingredients. The chocolate cookies contain bleached wheat flour, sugar, caramel color, cocoa, and corn flour, among other ingredients. These dessert sandwiches are round, thick, and easy to eat and hold.

Product specifications

Six sandwiches per box
Low-fat light vanilla ice cream
Cakey, chocolate cookies
Contains wheat, soy, and milk

Care and maintenance

Ice cream sandwiches should be stored in the freezer until they are served. To keep your ice cream from melting, it must be kept in a freezer and not a refrigerator. Ice cream sandwiches can be enjoyed and eaten by holding the sandwich between your fingers like a normal sandwich. To avoid any stickiness or ice cream melting on your fingers, eating your ice cream sandwich while keeping it halfway in its wrapper is a great idea.