12 min. read

The Best Breast Pump for 2023

Are you looking for the most comfortable way possible to express milk? Get one of these top-quality breast pumps.

As you approach the final weeks of your pregnancy, it’s time to start getting ready for the baby’s arrival. Given how important breastfeeding or breast milk is, you want to make sure that your baby gets every single drop of this liquid gold, especially during the very first months. However, sometimes you may not always be able to breastfeed. This, and many other reasons, make breast pumps an important accessory.

While the saturation of options has made the decision-making process more complicated than it needs to be, our curated list of the best breast pumps will simplify your buying process. So, whether you want one for yourself or as a gift for a close friend or family member, this review will be helpful.

How We Picked

  • Effective and Efficient

    The best breast pumps should be effective regardless of your feeding type (exclusive or mixed) or the type of breast pump (manual, electric, or battery-operated).

  • Adjustable Suction

    The best breast pumps have different suction modes or speeds that one can adjust as needed. This way, nursing mothers get to choose according to their preferences.

  • Easy to Use

    No one wants a breast pump that is too complicated to understand. The best breast pumps have a plug-and-go design that simplifies the process.

  • Cost-Effectiveness

    The cost of the breast pump isn’t always a factor in its efficacy. This is why we’ve sourced the best breast pumps in varying price ranges.

Our Top Picks

Our Top Pick

Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump

Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump

The Spectra S1 Plus breast pump will make your fourth trimester much easier.

The Spectra S1 Plus is an electric breast pump that operates on a closed system. This breast pump is popular among new and experienced mothers. With its portable design featuring a carrying handle, ease of use, suction strength, and versatility, it’s a no-brainer that this breast pump sells out fast.

Buy Now for $206.99

This breast pump is a bestseller for several reasons.

Our Runner-Up

Willow Wearable Breast Pump

Willow Wearable Breast Pump

The Willow Wearable Electric Breast Pump offers ease, convenience, and discretion.

The Willow Wearable Breast Pump is the definition of convenience. It is a hands-free, closed system, electric breast pump with a wireless design that fits inside your bra. This breast pump offers discretion for mothers who need it. Its sleek design and good battery life allow for prolonged use. However, its compact size can only hold small amounts of breast milk.

Buy Now for $549.99

This breast pump’s innovative design takes convenience to new levels.

Most Cost-Effective

Medela Harmony

Medela Harmony Breast Pump

The Medela Harmony manual breast pump offers optimal comfort at little to no cost.

The ergonomic design and distinctive handle of the Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump set it apart from its rivals. This breast pump is comfortable, affordable, and helps mothers produce a lot. The Medela Harmony offers great features at a great price. It is also portable, easy to use, and very easy to clean.

Buy Now

This manual breast pump is the best at its price point.

Everything We Recommend

Our Top Pick

Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump

Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump

The Spectra S1 Plus breast pump will make your fourth trimester much easier.

$206.99

Buy Now

Our Runner-Up

Willow Wearable Breast Pump

Willow Wearable Breast Pump

The Willow Wearable Electric Breast Pump offers ease, convenience, and discretion.

$549.99

Buy Now

Most Cost-Effective

Medela Harmony

Medela Harmony Breast Pump

The Medela Harmony manual breast pump offers optimal comfort at little to no cost.

Buy Now

Who This Is For

The products advertised here are for new or experienced nursing mothers who want to give their infants their best supply while giving themselves a break.

Electric vs. manual
Breast pumps could be electric or manual. While each has its strengths, a comparison is necessary. Electric breast pumps could be battery-operated, as you may need to charge them or use a disposable battery, while manual breast pumps are hand-operated and completely wireless.

Do I really need one?
For some mothers, breast pumps are non-negotiable, while others do just fine without them. Breast pumps prove most useful when the baby has trouble latching on or when the mother needs to be away from the infant, such as going back to work or running errands. However, if you’re doing just fine feeding your adorable baby directly or don’t need some time to yourself, then a breast pump will do you no good.

Does it have to be hospital-grade?
Hospital-grade breast pumps are rental, multi-user breast pumps with powerful motors and programming that enable mothers to produce the maximum amount of breast milk possible. Although hospital-grade breast pumps increase milk supply, you can do just fine with a personal double electric breast pump. So, no, your breast pump doesn’t have to be hospital-grade.

Is it worth splurging on?
Breast pumps are worth splurging on if you require convenience as a new or experienced mother. Also, splurging will give you a product with better value and longevity if you intend on having more children.

Why You Should Trust Us

We understand that finding the perfect breast pump might be a Goldilocks and the three bears situation. We’ve curated this list based on expert guidance from new and experienced mothers. We’ve also considered customer reviews from verified purchases, price-point, portability, ease of cleaning, and adjustable suction. We’ve tested these breast pumps on a diverse group of new and experienced mothers, and these are the options that emerged victorious.

How We Picked

These are the criteria that we used to curate this list of breast pumps.

Efficiency
The efficiency of the breast pump is a vital metric. To gauge the efficiency of our curated list of breast pumps, we tested them on several women and determined how the suction speed influences the amount of milk produced. These were the options that passed this test. Ideal breast pumps have adjustable suction controls with varying speeds and suction strengths. The mother must independently set suction speed and strength, as some women are more sensitive than others and may experience pain at speeds and strengths that others might not.

Easy to use and assemble
No mother wants to spend ample time figuring out how a breast pump works instead of feeding their infant. Breast pumps must be easy to use and assemble, reducing the time between expressions.

Design and style
The design and style of the breast pump influence a lot. For instance, some pumps are made with open systems that don’t have overflow protection as there’s no barrier between the milk and the pump, while others are made with closed systems that seal off the pump from the milk.

Size and weight
Breast pumps should be compact and lightweight to promote the ease of carrying and transporting them to different locations.

Price
While breast pumps are covered by your health insurance, if you want to purchase one outside of this coverage, then you should have the best options at different price points.

Noise
Breast pumps typically make a noise when in use. However, some pumps emit louder noises than others, and since no one wants to sound like a vibrating phone, it’s better to opt for the options with less sound.

Additional accessories
These breast pumps should come with additional accessories like a manufacturer’s warranty, breast shields, milk bags, cleaning brushes, etc.

Our Picks For You

Our Top Pick - Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump

Our Top Pick

Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump

Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump

The Spectra S1 Plus breast pump will make your fourth trimester much easier.

The Spectra S1 Plus is an electric breast pump that operates on a closed system. This breast pump is popular among new and experienced mothers. With its portable design featuring a carrying handle, ease of use, suction strength, and versatility, it’s a no-brainer that this breast pump sells out fast.

Buy Now for $206.99

Who It's For

This breast pump is best for exclusively pumping working moms who need enough milk to stash.

Why It's Great

The Spectra S1 double electric breast pump is great for a lot of reasons. Firstly, it’s an award-winning hospital-grade breast pump that has enough power to comfortably pump about five ounces of milk per breast in as little as 15 minutes. It is often covered by insurance and operates with a closed pump system. This breast pump is also double electric, which means you can pump one breast at a time or both simultaneously. It is cordless and rechargeable, quiet, and has a built-in night light.

Potential Flaws

Although it has a convenient handle, the Spectra S1 isn’t the most portable breast pump. Also, the breast pump vibrates during use.

Other Features

The Spectra S1 double electric breast pump is made of BPA-free material. It has a natural suction design that mimics breastfeeding and can be used for single or double expressions. This rechargeable electric breast pump is hygienic and has a barrier between the milk and the pump motor. It also has adjustable suction levels, an auto timer, and ultra-quiet motors for discretion.

As a hospital-grade breast pump, you can bank on the Spectra S1’s efficiency. This breast pump lets mothers set their preferred speeds and rhythms and can help them express several ounces in minutes.

Product Specifications

Product Dimensions: 7.9 x 7.9 x 6.7 inches
Batteries: Lithium polymer batteries
Pump Type: Electric
Weight: 3.3 pounds
Manufacturer: Spectra

Our Runner-Up - Willow Wearable Breast Pump

Our Runner-Up

Willow Wearable Breast Pump

Willow Wearable Breast Pump

The Willow Wearable Electric Breast Pump offers ease, convenience, and discretion.

The Willow Wearable Breast Pump is the definition of convenience. It is a hands-free, closed system, electric breast pump with a wireless design that fits inside your bra. This breast pump offers discretion for mothers who need it. Its sleek design and good battery life allow for prolonged use. However, its compact size can only hold small amounts of breast milk.

Buy Now for $549.99

Who It's For

The Willow Wearable Breast Pump is perfect for mothers who want to discreetly pump on the go.

Why It's Great

The Willow Wearable closed system breast pump is great because it is breast-shaped, wireless, hands-free, and fits inside your bra. It comes with a non-spill reusable container that prevents leaks. This breast pump enables mothers to pump discreetly and not have to wear pumping bras. This breast pump has a spill-proof design and permits pumping in any position.

Potential Flaws

While Willow’s wearable breast pump’s competitive advantage is the discretion it offers, people might still notice you’re pumping. This breast pump is pricy and some parts are sold separately. It can only hold a small amount of milk at a time.

Other Features

The Willow Wearable Breast Pump is double-electric, BPA-free, and lead-free. It offers 360-degree leak-proof mobility and offers hospital-grade suction with seven suction modes to choose from. This breast pump uses Smart Pumping and has a mobile app where one can track volume and adjust settings in real-time. It has a rechargeable battery and diverse flange sizes.

The Willow Wearable Breast Pump is effective in milk expression. It has smart sensors that detect letdown and automatically initiate expression. Its seven modes of adjustable suction, which go up to 245 mmHg, offer mothers the chance to fine-tune their preferences.

Product Specifications

Product Dimensions: 5.67 x 4.41 x 3.35 inches
Capacity: 12.5 ounces
Batteries: Rechargeable batteries
Pump Type: Electric
Weight: 0.78 pounds
Manufacturer: Willow

Most Cost-Effective - Medela Harmony Breast Pump

Most Cost-Effective

Medela Harmony

Medela Harmony Breast Pump

The Medela Harmony manual breast pump offers optimal comfort at little to no cost.

The ergonomic design and distinctive handle of the Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump set it apart from its rivals. This breast pump is comfortable, affordable, and helps mothers produce a lot. The Medela Harmony offers great features at a great price. It is also portable, easy to use, and very easy to clean.

Buy Now

Who It's For

The Medela Harmony manual breast pump is perfect for mothers who don’t intend to do a lot of pumping.

Why It's Great

The Medela Harmony manual breast pump is great because it’s easy to use and easy to clean. Because it’s a manual pump, this breast pump has no whirring sound, making the Medela Harmony noiseless and discrete. It’s very portable, can fit in most bags, and comes with a breast shield.

Potential Flaws

The Medela Harmony manual breast pump lets you do all the work. This breast pump can lose suction over time as the O-ring can become ragged. However, it’s easy to replace this part. Although effective, this breast pump might be tiring for women who want to pump regularly. However, its patented design allows mothers to pump moderate amounts.

Other Features

The Medela Harmony manual breast pump has an ergonomic swivel handle that permits users to find their sweet spot or most comfortable position where they can pump. This breast pump offers convenience and ease that’s not typically associated with a manual breast pump.

Product Specifications

Product Dimensions: 3.1 x 4.2 x 8.1 inches
Pump Type: Manual
Weight: 14.4 ounces
Manufacturer: Medela

Almost Made The Cut - Bellababy Double Electric Breast Pump

Almost Made The Cut

Bellababy Double Electric Breast Pump

Bellababy Double Electric Breast Pump

For experienced mothers, Bellababy's Double Electric Breast Pump is a no-brainer.

The Bellababy Double Electric Breast Pump has a lot to offer. From its compact and closed-system design to its extended battery life and convenience, this breast pump is great for moms on the go. Additionally, the Bellababy Double Electric breast pump can be used wirelessly and has different suction speeds.

Buy Now for $59.99

Who It's For

The Bellababy Double Electric Breast Pump is ideal for mothers who want the power of an electric breast pump without breaking the bank.

Why It's Great

Several features make the Bellababy Double Electric breast pump great. This portable breast pump comes with an LCD touchscreen control panel, has a closed system technology, is double electric, and is lightweight with a large battery capacity and multiple suction levels. Mothers can also use it wirelessly.

Potential Flaws

Several features make the Bellababy Double Electric breast pump great. This portable breast pump comes with an LCD touchscreen control panel, has a closed system technology, is double electric, and is lightweight with a large battery capacity and multiple suction levels. Mothers can also use it wirelessly.

Other Features

The Bellababy Double Electric Breast Pump has a touch panel high-definition display. It’s a closed system with four modes, nine suction levels, and a 2200mAH Li-ion battery that can last 100 hours. The Bellababy’s suction keeps going even on a low battery. It’s very effective in comfortably pumping milk.

Product Specifications

Product Dimensions: 14.02 x 10.24 x 4.13 inches
Pump Type: Electric
Weight: 1 pound
Manufacturer: Bellababy
Battery: Li-ion batteries

Care and Maintenance

How to clean
Breast pumps should be cleaned before and after use with hot water and soap. Fill a bowl or basin with hot water and liquid soap. Scrub according to the manufacturer’s guide, rinse, and then dry.

How to disinfect
You can disinfect or sterilize your breast pump by disassembling the parts that come in contact with the breast or milk and boiling them in a pot of hot water. Do this with the lid closed and for a few minutes. You can also use steam to disinfect the breast pump.

Where and how to store it when carrying it around
The curated list of breast pumps is easily portable and can be stored in handbags or storage nooks

Where and how to store when not in use
When the breast pump is not in use, you can sanitize the parts and store them in a clean, dry area, which could be a storage nook or closet.