The Best Toilet Plunger for 2023

Make fixing a clogged toilet or drain easy and mess-free with one of the most dependable toilet plungers available on the market

The Best Toilet Plunger for 2023

There are many household tools that we use and appreciate daily. However, there are others we don’t give the recognition and praise they rightly deserve. The toilet plunger is a clear example of an underrated household tool.

Clogged drains and toilets are both common issues in our homes. They may not occur frequently, but when they do, the results can be disastrous. Thankfully, dealing with clogged toilets or sinks doesn’t always require a handyperson. With a good toilet plunger, you can efficiently deal with clogs when they occur.

But, like with every other household tool, many different toilet plunger options are available, which might make it hard for you to choose one from the lot. This is why we have compiled this list of the most reliable plungers for you.

How We Picked

  • Strength of Suction

    The suction strength depends on how fast and easy it will be to unclog a blocked toilet. The best toilet plunger should be powerful enough to finish the job quickly.

  • Material and Durability

    To work efficiently, the best toilet plungers are made from durable materials that boost the results during use.

  • Easy Grip

    A plunger with a comfortable grip is preferred to ensure you can easily use the plunger without experiencing discomfort.

  • Cost-Effectiveness

    Plungers shouldn’t cost much. We reviewed plungers that work effectively and are affordable.

Our Top Picks

Our Top Pick

Korky 96-4AM Universal Plunger

Korky 96-4AM Universal Plunger

This plunger is perfect for old and modern toilet bowls

This plunger gives a perfect and secure fit on all toilet bowl types. The lower portion of the cup of this plunger has a thin wall that makes it soft and pliable to conform to any bowl shape. Furthermore, it has a unique T-shaped handle. This handle is very comfortable because it is easy to grip and use. The sturdy and compact handle is also adjustable, so you can adjust the length to suit you.

Buy Now for $19.98

It is designed with a unique shape to fit any type of toilet bowl.

Our Runner-Up

NEIKO Toilet Plunger

NEIKO Toilet Plunger

A full cleaning kit that includes six authentic disposable refills, a storage caddy, and a toilet wand

This plunger has layered flanges that are responsible for its heavy-duty suction. The NEIKO toilet plunger’s cup has four steps, each of different diameters. This creates the tightest seal of all our picks. In addition, it has an all-angle design that lets you quickly reach all corners of a toilet bowl. It has a standard-style metal handle that is resistant to mold and rust. The smooth edge and bottom, with no interior ridges, prevent residue buildup.

Buy Now for $17.54

A flange plunger that provides suction from all angles and a tight seal.

Most Cost-Effective

Supply Guru Heavy Duty Toilet Plunger

Supply Guru Heavy Duty Toilet Plunger

A simple, classic plunger with tremendous suction power

Supply Guru’s Heavy Duty toilet plunger is a traditional cup plunger. It features a long, sturdy wooden handle that makes it easy to use. Not to mention its flat rubber cup that creates an above-average seal. It’s not the most beautiful or sophisticated plunger out there. Still, it has every essential feature to tackle a clogged toilet. It is best for flat drains.

Buy Now for $7.80

This classic plunger packs a lot of suction.

Everything We Recommend

Our Top Pick

Korky 96-4AM Universal Plunger

Korky 96-4AM Universal Plunger

This plunger is perfect for old and modern toilet bowls

$19.98

Buy Now

Our Runner-Up

NEIKO Toilet Plunger

NEIKO Toilet Plunger

A full cleaning kit that includes six authentic disposable refills, a storage caddy, and a toilet wand

$17.54

Buy Now

Most Cost-Effective

Supply Guru Heavy Duty Toilet Plunger

Supply Guru Heavy Duty Toilet Plunger

A simple, classic plunger with tremendous suction power

$7.80

Buy Now

Who This Is For

Toilet plungers are a must-have for every home. You may only appreciate its importance once you need to use one. A good toilet plunger helps you deal with a toilet clog emergency as soon as it comes up. In addition, it saves you the cost of hiring a plumber to unclog your toilet for you.

Toilet plungers are also excellent tools for plumbers and people in charge of maintaining facilities in an apartment, flat, office, etc.

Toilet plunger vs. drain plunger

“Drain” is a universal term. Your toilets, sinks, bathtubs, bathrooms, and whatnot all have drains. Therefore, a drain plunger would work for all the facilities mentioned above. A toilet plunger, on the other hand, is a unique toilet. A toilet plunger features designs that make it strong and easy to use for toilets. Depending on what suits you, you can choose a One-for-all (drain) plunger or a specific toilet plunger.

Different types of plungers

There are five types of toilet plungers. Each of them has unique features. Knowing the different toilet plunger types will help you make the right choice.

The traditional cup plunger

This is simply a suction cup that connects to a stick. They are widely available and budget-friendly. However, they don’t always create the perfect seal on most toilets.

The beehive plunger

It has a wide shape and a flange (a projecting edge). They’re great for most toilets but not very suitable for small ones.

The bellow plunger

This plunger has a collapsible and expandable drainage pipe. They are also popularly known as “accordion plungers.” They are powerful and well-suited for toilets. However, they may be hard to use.

The flange plunger

It is similar to the traditional cup plunger, differing only by an included rubber flap. The rubber flap ensures the cup can form a seal on the curve. It’s the best toilet plunger, although the flap can quickly get dirty.

The taze plunger

This plumber’s favorite has a steep curve. The steep curve helps to clean long pipes quickly. This makes it the best toilet plungers for plumbers that want to unclog toilets and sewer pipes. It is not readily available because it is not intended for regular, domestic use.

Why You Should Trust Us

We researched multiple plumbing sites to understand the features the best toilet plunger should have. Armed with knowledge from professionals, we surveyed the multiple toilet plunger options available. We picked high-quality plungers that scored high marks in critical factors such as suction strength, ease of use, affordability, and manufacturing material quality.

How We Picked

To ensure that we picked only the best, we considered some critical factors in our evaluation — the power of the toilet plunger, for example. We chose plungers with powerful suction so that you can unclog the toilet in a short time. We also considered the materials used to make these plungers. We picked plungers made from durable and quality materials, favoring metal handles because they are more hygienic and durable than wooden ones.

We ensured that the handles of our choices were long enough to make the task easier, and they sported rubber heads that could work with most toilet types. In addition, we confirmed that our picks are as easy to use as they are powerful. We focused on the style and design of these plungers because they can directly affect the plunger’s efficiency.

Finally, we picked the best toilet plungers that are worth the money you spend on them.

Our Picks For You

Our Top Pick - Korky 96-4AM Universal Plunger

Our Top Pick

Korky 96-4AM Universal Plunger

Korky 96-4AM Universal Plunger

This plunger is perfect for old and modern toilet bowls

This plunger gives a perfect and secure fit on all toilet bowl types. The lower portion of the cup of this plunger has a thin wall that makes it soft and pliable to conform to any bowl shape. Furthermore, it has a unique T-shaped handle. This handle is very comfortable because it is easy to grip and use. The sturdy and compact handle is also adjustable, so you can adjust the length to suit you.

Buy Now for $19.98

Who It's For

This plunger is perfect if you’re looking for a plunger for different bowl types. It’s also great if you prefer a T-shaped handle to a straight or round one. It is suitable for family use since its handle is adjustable for the many hands in the family. The four-pronged rubber of the Korky is impressively durable. Therefore, you might want to consider this if you’re looking for something to last through the years.

Why It's Great

Distinguished by its beehive-shaped cup, the Korky 96-4AM has a thin, soft, and pliable lower cup portion that conforms to every toilet bowl. It also has two rings of rubber at the midsection of the cup. This prevents it from collapsing in on itself. The upper portion of the cup is thicker to maintain the shape of the plunger. The T-shaped handle of this plunger makes it easy to use. With the handle, you can have a comfortable grip and control the pressure of the plunge.

Potential Flaws

It doesn't come with a drip tray holder. In addition, it may fit all bowl types, but the seal is not very tight on some toilet bowls. Therefore, some backsplash may occur. Some customers also complained that this plunger might trap unwanted matter, making it harder to clean. In addition, some reviews state that the handle feels flimsy. You may need to be extra cautious when holding the handle because you don’t want it to break.

Other Features

The adjustable handle of this plunger makes it easy to store under sinks or vanities. In addition, it can hold about seven cups of water. Therefore, it can send a good amount of water down the toilet pipe. The company that produces this plunger also allows a return, refund, and replacement in case you need one. The plunger is also Kohler-recommended and made it to the top 100 best new home products in 2014.

Product Specifications

Color: Black & White
Handle Material: Plastic
Flap Material: Rubber
Cup Material: Plastic
Grip: T-shaped Handle
Holder Included: No
Type: Beehive Plunger
Product Dimensions(L×W×H): 6 × 6 × 17 inches
Item Weight: 1.61 pounds

Our Runner-Up - NEIKO Toilet Plunger

Our Runner-Up

NEIKO Toilet Plunger

NEIKO Toilet Plunger

A full cleaning kit that includes six authentic disposable refills, a storage caddy, and a toilet wand

This plunger has layered flanges that are responsible for its heavy-duty suction. The NEIKO toilet plunger’s cup has four steps, each of different diameters. This creates the tightest seal of all our picks. In addition, it has an all-angle design that lets you quickly reach all corners of a toilet bowl. It has a standard-style metal handle that is resistant to mold and rust. The smooth edge and bottom, with no interior ridges, prevent residue buildup.

Buy Now for $17.54

Who It's For

This plunger is perfect if you prioritize tight seals to ensure no backsplash. It’s also great for people looking for a lightweight plunger. The plunger also has a peg hole, so if you would love to hang up your plunger, you should go for this. This plunger has fantastic features that ensure it stays clean. If that’s a factor you’re interested in, you should go for the NEIKO toilet plunger.

Why It's Great

The NEIKO features a four-step suction cup that creates impressive suction power. The plunger will also fit in different toilet sizes because the four steps have different diameters. The cups are made of durable rubber that is strong yet pliable. In addition to that, the cups leverage all the angles. Therefore, this plunger creates the tightest seal of our picks. Additionally, the aluminum handle is lightweight with an easy grip for practical use.

Potential Flaws

It might not seal some older toilet bowls effectively. Also, the plunger doesn’t come with a drip tray holder. In addition, you may find the aluminum handle weak. Some customers noted that their NEIKO plungers got a dent on the first use. There’s also the issue of rubber odor. Some customers stated they had to keep the plunger out of the house because of the smell.

Other Features

The cup has smooth edges and a smooth bottom that prevents residue buildup. The aluminum handle is remarkably resistant to rust and mold. There's a peg hole at the handle's top end, so you can hang it if you choose. You have the choice of adding a little more money to get a cleaning system. You can also return, refund, or replace this plunger within 30 days if purchased.

Product Specifications

Color: Black
Handle Material: Aluminum
Head Material: Rubber
Cup Material: Rubber
Grip: Standard
Holder Included: No
Type: Flange
Product Dimensions(L×W×H): 24 × 6 × 1 inches
Item Weight: 0.85 pounds

Most Cost-Effective - Supply Guru Heavy Duty Toilet Plunger

Most Cost-Effective

Supply Guru Heavy Duty Toilet Plunger

Supply Guru Heavy Duty Toilet Plunger

A simple, classic plunger with tremendous suction power

Supply Guru’s Heavy Duty toilet plunger is a traditional cup plunger. It features a long, sturdy wooden handle that makes it easy to use. Not to mention its flat rubber cup that creates an above-average seal. It’s not the most beautiful or sophisticated plunger out there. Still, it has every essential feature to tackle a clogged toilet. It is best for flat drains.

Buy Now for $7.80

Who It's For

It's great if you love traditional cup plungers' classic and old-school style. If you'd love to use your plunger on flat drains, too, you can try this. It’s inexpensive and will suit those looking for something affordable. This plunger is for you if you prefer wooden plunger handles to metal.

Why It's Great

It has powerful suction and a plunging action. If it fits your toilet bowl, your task will be done in record time. Its wooden handle offers an excellent grip and comfort. The 18 inches handle length is also great because you don’t have to bend so much.

Potential Flaws

It is powerful for flat drains but less effective for toilets. Reviews online show that the wood can easily break with use. The rubber cup, although effective, is not very thick. The cup becomes inverted if you push too hard or use it a lot. The rubber may also break off in time. Lastly, this plunger isn’t attractive. You may find the basic, old-school look unsatisfying.

Other Features

It is cheap, sturdy, decent, and easy to assemble. Due to its simplicity, it’s effortless to use. The manufacturer also allows refunds, returns, and replacements within 30 days of receipt.

Product Specifications

Color: Red
Handle Material: Wooden
Flap Material: No Flap
Cup Material: Rubber
Grip: Standard
Holder Included: No
Type: Traditional
Product Dimensions(L×W×H): 12 × 2 × 0.3 inches
Item Weight: 0.5 pounds

Almost Made The Cut - Simplehuman Toilet Plunger

Almost Made The Cut

Simplehuman Toilet Plunger

Simplehuman Toilet Plunger

A plunger with a beautiful, ergonomic & drip-free design

‘Beautiful' and 'Stylish' are the two words that come to mind when you see this plunger. This beautiful plunger comes with a caddy, adding to the lovely design. The caddy has a magnetic collar that binds the cover of the plunger handle. That way, you can pick up and carry the plunger without dripping. It is a flange-type plunger that’s most effective in modern toilets with a narrow or elongated drain.

Buy Now

Who It's For

This is your plunger if you're looking for something that catches the eye and performs exceptionally. If you prioritize a drip-free process, you can try this. It's also great for those who love flanged plungers. Since it has a caddy, the plunger stays out of sight. This makes it ideal for those who love being discreet about anything concerning their toilets. If you’re looking for a plunger with a warranty, this is the one.

Why It's Great

The Simplehman plunger is gorgeous, and its ergonomic design makes it easy to use. The handle is made of stainless steel, which is durable and gives a good look. It is also rounded at the top, which some people find comfortable. It includes a drip tray holder so you can have a drip-free process. As a flange plunger, it provides sufficient suction.

Potential Flaws

The plunger often requires extra effort for excellent performance. Furthermore, many customers complained that there was a significant reduction in performance with time. You’ll need a lot more effort to use it the second time than when you used it the first. In addition, the plunger doesn’t fit down to the bottom of the toilet bowl. Lastly, it's costlier than the rest of our picks.

Other Features

The only pick with a caddy (drip tray holder). The caddy has a magnet around its collar. This magnetic collar keeps the plunger attached to the caddy so you can carry them together. The caddy also hides the plunger out of sight when not in use. In addition, the manufacturer offers a 5-year warranty.

Product Specifications

Color: Black
Handle Material: Stainless Steel
Flap Material: Rubber
Cup Material: Plastic
Grip: Rounded Handle
Holder Included: Yes
Type: Flange
Product Dimensions(L×W×H): 7.9 × 7.1 × 23.1 inches
Item Weight: 2.16 pounds

Care and Maintenance

The best way to care for and maintain your toilet plunger properly is by using it correctly. Here’s how.

  • Firstly, put on your rubber gloves. Clearing a clogged toilet is unsanitary and filthy splash-backs may occur.
  • Your toilet should have enough water to cover the rim of the plunger head. Add water to your toilet bowl if it doesn’t.
  • Angling your plunger optimizes the unclogging. You should flex your plunger over the drain. That allows it to fill the cup with water and seal it tightly around the drain.
  • You have to ensure the seal around the drain remains tight. You know it’s loose if you see bubbles from the plunger cup rather than down the toilet. If it’s loose, you have to readjust the plunger.
  • Now it’s time for you to plunge. Pull the handle firmly for twenty seconds. Don’t use one long pull, as that may dislodge the seal. Instead, use firm motions. This will clear the clog completely.

A toilet plunger does a dirty job and would require cleaning. Here’s how to clean your plunger.

  • Pour three caps of bleach into your toilet. You can also use 5% apple cider vinegar if you prefer.
  • Soak and swirl the plunger vigorously in the toilet water.
  • Flush the toilet with fresh water.
  • Soak the plunger into the toilet again and swirl.
  • Remove the plunger and let it dry.

You must remember to wash your hands after plunging and cleaning the plunger, even if you wore gloves. Toilets only sometimes get clogged to the point of using a plunger. Usually, you can clear toilet clogs with other more straightforward and less demanding methods. However, you must use a toilet plunger when all other approaches prove wrong. This is because it shows that the clog is a serious one.