'Josephine' Sweeps IndieWire's 2026 Sundance Critics Survey

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The 2026 Sundance Film Festival has delivered a resounding verdict: independent cinema is leaning into deeply personal narratives, complex character studies, and a willingness to tackle challenging themes. The overwhelming success of 'Josephine' in IndieWire's Critics Survey highlights a clear preference for films that prioritize nuanced character development, signaling a potential shift in what audiences and critics alike are seeking from independent film.

Why it matters

The rise of character-driven cinema, the continued exploration of societal issues through documentary filmmaking, the blurring lines between documentary and narrative, the growing prominence of international cinema, and the recognition of first-time filmmakers all point to significant trends shaping the future of independent film. These developments reflect a broader appetite for stories that delve deeper into the human experience, challenge traditional boundaries, and amplify diverse voices.

The details

The dominance of 'Josephine' across multiple categories – Best Feature, Directing, Screenwriting, and Performances from both Mason Reeves and Channing Tatum – underscores the audience's preference for films that prioritize nuanced character development. This trend is not new, but the degree of consensus around 'Josephine' suggests it's intensifying. Audiences are increasingly drawn to stories that explore the inner lives of characters, their motivations, and their struggles, rather than relying solely on plot-driven narratives. The high ranking of William Greaves' 'Once Upon a Time in Harlem' and the inclusion of titles like 'Give Me the Ball,' 'Nuisance Bear,' and 'The History of Concrete' in the top ten also highlight the enduring power of documentary filmmaking to illuminate historical and cultural contexts. The inclusion of 'The AI Doc: Or How I Became an Apocaloptimist' suggests a growing interest in documentaries that experiment with form and address emerging technologies, blurring the lines between documentary and narrative.

• The 2026 Sundance Film Festival took place in January 2026.

What they’re saying

What’s next

The continued success of character-driven independent films and the growing prominence of international and experimental documentaries will likely shape the programming and reception of future Sundance Film Festivals, as filmmakers and audiences alike seek out stories that challenge traditional boundaries and amplify diverse perspectives.