Suspect Video in Guthrie Case Raises Questions, Says Former FBI Official

Dan Bongino analyzes new footage and highlights strange aspects that could provide clues to the investigation.

Published on Feb. 10, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Former FBI deputy director Dan Bongino analyzed new video footage of the suspect in the Nancy Guthrie case on Fox News, highlighting several strange aspects that he believes could provide important clues. Bongino noted the suspect's unusual behavior, such as the way he was carrying a firearm and his apparent surprise at the presence of a doorbell camera. Bongino also speculated about whether the suspect could be an insider or a local, and whether the crime was related to a kidnapping for ransom or a burglary gone wrong.

Why it matters

The Guthrie case has captivated national attention, and any new information or analysis from law enforcement experts like Bongino could help advance the investigation and provide valuable insights into the perpetrator's identity and motives.

The details

In the video, Bongino pointed out several peculiarities, such as the suspect's apparent familiarity with the area, his unusual way of carrying a firearm, and his seemingly amateurish attempt to cover the doorbell camera. Bongino also discussed the possibility that the suspect could be an insider, such as a gardener or electrician who had previously worked in the Guthrie home, or a local with knowledge of the area. Additionally, Bongino raised the question of whether the crime was related to a kidnapping for ransom or a burglary that went wrong.

  • The new video footage was analyzed by Bongino on Tuesday, February 10, 2026.

The players

Dan Bongino

A former deputy director of the FBI who was recently rehired by Fox News as a contributor.

Martha MacCallum

The Fox News host who interviewed Bongino about the Guthrie case suspect video.

Nancy Guthrie

The victim in the high-profile case that has captivated national attention.

Samantha Guthrie

The daughter of Nancy Guthrie, who has been posting videos related to the case.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Well, I see a lot of things. There seems to be at some point, you know, familiarity with the area. If you notice when he walks up, he has his head down. Maybe he thinks there's some surveillance camera outside he's missing, but then he seems if you look, he seems surprised — I see it playing right now — he seems like he's going to knock on the door, and then seems surprised by the presence of that doorbell camera right there. And then instead of having a simple item like a piece of tape, he goes out and grabs in kind of amateurish manner, you know, some plant that he tries to cover it with. It just seems quite odd.”

— Dan Bongino, Former FBI Deputy Director (Fox News)

“And another thing that sticks out to me is, you know, having been not just in law enforcement, being a gun carrier my whole life, that's a very unusual way to carry a firearm. I mean, they have inside the waistband holsters. Now, I don't know what type of firearm it is, I can't see from the picture, I'm watching it right here. Maybe it's a revolver, I don't know. But that's an unusually large holster to be carrying in that manner.”

— Dan Bongino, Former FBI Deputy Director (Fox News)

What’s next

The FBI's digital video enhancement team is likely working to analyze the footage and extract additional clues, such as the suspect's height and facial features. Investigators will also be examining DNA evidence collected from the scene to determine if it matches any known individuals.

The takeaway

This case highlights the importance of forensic analysis and expert insights in complex criminal investigations. Bongino's observations about the suspect's behavior and the way he was carrying a firearm could provide valuable leads for law enforcement as they work to identify and apprehend the perpetrator.