Affluent Upper East Side Residents Erupt in Outrage Over Planned Homeless Shelter

Community members cite rushed approval, safety concerns, and lack of transparency from city officials

Published on Feb. 12, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Residents of New York City's affluent Upper East Side neighborhood packed a heated public meeting to protest a planned women's homeless shelter, accusing city officials of deliberately rushing the approval process and failing to properly address community concerns over the shelter's proximity to schools and daycares. Opponents argued the location was unsuitable and accused developers of prioritizing profits over neighborhood well-being, while city representatives and some locals emphasized the urgent need for homeless services in the area.

Why it matters

The controversy highlights the ongoing tensions between providing critical social services and addressing the concerns of affluent communities that often resist the placement of homeless shelters in their neighborhoods. The case raises questions about transparency in the approval process, the balance between community input and urgent social needs, and the potential impact of homeless facilities on surrounding areas.

The details

The planned 250-bed women's shelter is set to open around April, having been converted from a previous men's facility. Residents accused city officials of fast-tracking the deal with little community input, only informing local leaders that the project was indefinitely shelved in early 2025 before suddenly announcing it as nearly completed in January 2026. Opponents cited the shelter's proximity to schools and daycares as a major safety concern, and criticized the lack of thorough criminal background checks for potential residents. City representatives acknowledged valid concerns but emphasized the urgent need for homeless services in the district.

  • The city reportedly told local leaders in early 2025 that the project was indefinitely shelved.
  • In January 2026, the city reannounced the shelter as an active and nearly completed facility, giving the community just weeks to organize before it opens.
  • The shelter is slated to open around April 2026.

The players

Housing Solutions of New York (HSNY)

The organization overseeing the development of the planned women's homeless shelter.

Bonnie Barend

A community member who criticized the lack of notification and the suitability of the shelter's location.

Dr. Xellex Rivera

The Chief Program Officer of HSNY, who explained the organization's process for screening potential shelter residents.

Valerie Mason

The chairperson of Community Board 8 Manhattan, who acknowledged the heated atmosphere of the meeting.

Todd "TJ" Stein

A Community Board 8 Manhattan member who expressed disappointment with the rushed approval process.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“What we're offended by is the lack of notification and the wrong location. It shouldn't be here.”

— Bonnie Barend, Community member

“Unacceptable! That is not a background check.”

— Unnamed resident

“That is fair. I 100% agree with everybody. That is fair.”

— Dr. Xellex Rivera, Chief Program Officer, HSNY

“You're not advocating for us!”

— Unnamed resident

“This was just unfortunately, not a really well-run meeting. And that just sucks... we as a community had three weeks to basically be thrown this information.”

— Todd "TJ" Stein, Community Board 8 Manhattan member

What’s next

The judge in the case will decide on Tuesday whether or not to allow the shelter to open as planned.

The takeaway

The controversy over the planned homeless shelter in the affluent Upper East Side highlights the ongoing tensions between providing critical social services and addressing the concerns of wealthy communities that often resist the placement of such facilities in their neighborhoods. The case raises questions about transparency, community input, and the balance between urgent social needs and the potential impact on surrounding areas.