'Super Mario Galaxy Movie' Sequel Fails to Capture Magic of Original

Critics say the latest installment in the video game franchise adaptation is a disappointing letdown.

Apr. 4, 2026 at 10:55am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The sequel to the 2024 hit 'Super Mario Movie' has been panned by critics, who say the new film 'The Super Mario Galaxy Movie' simply goes through the motions without the joy and fun of the original. The plot follows a similar kidnapping storyline, with Princess Rosalina being abducted by Bowser Jr. to power his Boomsday cannon. While the visuals are bright and colorful, the overall tone is described as lacking the infectious charm of the first movie.

Why it matters

The 'Super Mario' franchise is one of the most popular and lucrative video game properties, with a massive built-in fan base. The first movie adaptation was a surprise hit, grossing over $1 billion globally. However, this sequel seems to have missed the mark, potentially disappointing fans and general audiences alike.

The details

Despite having a similar kidnapping plot to the previous film, with Mario and Luigi coming to the aid of Princess Peach's sister Rosalina, critics say 'The Super Mario Galaxy Movie' lacks the sense of joy and fun that made the original so engaging. The action and visuals are described as manic and overstimulating, with the directors Aaron Horvath and Michael Jelenic accused of simply 'going through the motions' rather than capturing the magic of the source material.

  • The Super Mario Galaxy Movie' was released in theaters on April 4, 2026.
  • The first 'Super Mario Movie' was released in 2024.

The players

Aaron Horvath

Co-director of 'The Super Mario Galaxy Movie' and the previous 'Super Mario Movie'.

Michael Jelenic

Co-director of 'The Super Mario Galaxy Movie' and the previous 'Super Mario Movie'.

Chris Pratt

Voice actor who plays Mario in the 'Super Mario' movie franchise.

Anya Taylor-Joy

Voice actress who plays Princess Peach in the 'Super Mario' movie franchise.

Jack Black

Voice actor who plays Bowser Sr. in 'The Super Mario Galaxy Movie'.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“There's a sense here that all involved are simply going through the motions, something that does not bode well for the many sequels to come or the non-fans who will have to endure them.”

— Chuck Koplinski, Film Critic

“I sympathize with any grandparents who, wanting to give their kids a break by suggesting they spend some time with their grandkids, wind up at the local multiplex and stumble into this film.”

— Chuck Koplinski, Film Critic

What’s next

With the disappointing reception to 'The Super Mario Galaxy Movie', it remains to be seen if the franchise can recapture the magic of the first film in future installments. Fans will be closely watching to see if the directors and creative team can inject more energy and originality into the next 'Super Mario' movie.

The takeaway

The 'Super Mario' movie franchise has the potential to be a beloved family-friendly series, but this sequel suggests the creative team may be struggling to maintain the high standards set by the first film. Audiences will be hoping future installments can recapture the sense of joy and fun that made the original such a hit.