Guardians Winning Without Breaking the Bank in MLB Free Agency

Cleveland's small-market team continues to find success through player development and collaborative coaching.

Published on Feb. 15, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The Cleveland Guardians, a small-market MLB team, have consistently made the postseason despite not spending big in free agency. Their general manager, Mike Chernoff, explains that they have to "win with our own players" by relying on strong scouting, player analysis, and collaborative coaching to develop talent. The team is known for its "Cleveland Pitching Factory" that produces quality starting pitchers. Manager Stephen Vogt says the team focuses on improving every day and doesn't pay attention to outside noise or predictions, instead just worrying about their own objectives.

Why it matters

The Guardians' success as a small-market team provides an alternative model to the big-spending approach of many MLB franchises. Their ability to consistently field competitive teams despite financial constraints highlights the importance of effective player development, scouting, and collaborative coaching. This story offers insights into how small-market teams can thrive in the modern baseball landscape.

The details

Guardians GM Mike Chernoff explains that the team can't compete in free agency like big-market teams, so they have to "do things very differently." This includes relying on their strong scouting, analytics, and coaching staff to develop their own players. The team has won 6 division titles in the past decade and made the postseason 7 out of 10 years. Chernoff credits the collaborative efforts of the team's pitching group for the Guardians' success in developing starting pitchers, often referred to as the "Cleveland Pitching Factory." Manager Stephen Vogt says the team tries hard not to pay attention to outside predictions and expectations, instead focusing on their own objectives and getting better every day.

  • The Guardians' media day took place in Spring Training in Scottsdale, Arizona.

The players

Mike Chernoff

The general manager of the Cleveland Guardians, who has led the team's efforts to build a contender despite financial constraints as a small-market franchise.

Stephen Vogt

The manager of the Cleveland Guardians, who took over for Terry Francona and continues the team's winning tradition.

Chris Antonetti

The president of baseball operations for the Cleveland Guardians, who has worked alongside GM Mike Chernoff to build the team's success.

Terry Francona

The former manager of the Cleveland Guardians, who laid the foundation for the team's consistent success.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“In today's economic system in Major League Baseball, we can't compete in free agency. So, we have to do things very differently.”

— Mike Chernoff, General Manager (ClutchPoints)

“To me, it's a combination of all of the factors. I think our group, our pitching group, is so collaborative. And it has to be a joint effort.”

— Mike Chernoff, General Manager (ClutchPoints)

“I don't know if it puts a chip on our shoulder. We try really hard not to pay attention to that. We focus on us.”

— Stephen Vogt, Manager (ClutchPoints)

What’s next

The Guardians will look to continue their winning ways in the 2026 season, as they aim to make the playoffs once again despite being overlooked by many experts who favor the improved Detroit Tigers and Kansas City Royals in the American League Central division.

The takeaway

The Cleveland Guardians' success as a small-market team demonstrates the value of effective player development, collaborative coaching, and a focus on internal improvement over big-spending in free agency. Their model provides a blueprint for other small-market franchises to build sustainable contenders in Major League Baseball.