The Setlist Hosts Discuss Favorite Fictional Bands

Melissa Chase and Anson Kessinger debate the best and worst made-up musical acts.

Apr. 17, 2026 at 2:56pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An abstract, minimalist illustration featuring sharp, angular black shapes representing musical instruments and symbols, set against a high-contrast red and white background, conceptually representing the discussion of made-up musical acts.The Setlist podcast explores the enduring appeal of fictional bands and artists in pop culture.Richmond Today

On the latest episode of the entertainment podcast The Setlist, hosts Melissa Chase and Anson Kessinger discussed their favorite and least favorite fictional bands and artists from movies, TV shows, and books. The hosts invited listeners to share their own opinions on the best and worst made-up musical acts.

Why it matters

Fictional bands and artists have become a popular part of pop culture, with some achieving cult status and even releasing real music. The Setlist's discussion highlights how these imaginary acts can resonate with audiences and reflect broader trends in music and entertainment.

The details

Chase and Kessinger covered a range of fictional bands and artists on the episode, praising the authenticity of groups like Spinal Tap from This Is Spinal Tap while criticizing less convincing acts. The hosts encouraged listeners to email in their own thoughts on the best and worst made-up musical acts.

  • The Setlist episode aired on April 17, 2026.

The players

Melissa Chase

A co-host of the entertainment podcast The Setlist.

Anson Kessinger

A co-host of the entertainment podcast The Setlist.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Did we miss your favorite made-up artist? Do you disagree with some of our worst fictional bands? Shoot us an email at thesetlist@wric.com and let us know!”

— Melissa Chase and Anson Kessinger, Co-hosts, The Setlist

The takeaway

The Setlist's discussion of fictional bands and artists highlights how these imaginary acts have become an integral part of pop culture, with some achieving a devoted following and even releasing real music. The hosts' invitation for listener feedback underscores the enduring appeal of these made-up musical acts.