Vail Resorts Fights Lawsuit Threatening Key Park City Chairlifts

Resort operator files motion to dismiss complaint over land rights dispute that could halt operations at two major ski lifts.

Apr. 16, 2026 at 6:35pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A high-end, photorealistic studio still-life photograph featuring a polished metal ski lift chair and a set of ski poles arranged elegantly on a clean, monochromatic background, conceptually representing the abstract corporate strategy and legal disputes surrounding the operations of a ski resort.A legal battle over land rights threatens to disrupt the operations of key ski lifts at Park City Mountain, with far-reaching consequences for the local economy.Park City Today

Vail Resorts has filed a motion to dismiss a lawsuit brought by UI Charitable Advisors, a Provo-based nonprofit, that claims the resort is trespassing on its land and threatens to shut down operations of the Timberline and Iron Mountain Express chairlifts at Park City Mountain. Vail Resorts argues the nonprofit was aware of the existing easement agreement when it purchased the land in 2024 and that closing the lifts would cause immediate and irreversible damage to the local ecosystem and economy.

Why it matters

The potential shutdown of these critical chairlifts would have far-reaching consequences, including job losses for seasonal ski resort workers, declining property values for homeowners in the nearby Colony HOA who rely on ski-in access, and broader economic ripple effects on the local hospitality, transportation, and restaurant businesses that depend on a fully operational mountain.

The details

The dispute centers around a specific parcel of land within The Colony at White Pine Canyon that UI Charitable Advisors purchased in December 2024. The nonprofit alleges the legal rights to operate the Timberline and Iron Mountain Express lifts, known as easements, were never properly transferred to Vail Resorts during its acquisition of the mountain. However, Vail Resorts argues a June 2003 easement agreement filed with the Summit County Recorder grants the resort the right to operate these lifts, and that UI Charitable Advisors was aware of the active ski operations when they bought the land.

  • In December 2024, UI Charitable Advisors purchased the parcel of land within The Colony at White Pine Canyon.
  • In June 2003, the easement agreement granting Vail Resorts the right to operate the Timberline and Iron Mountain Express lifts was filed with the Summit County Recorder.

The players

Vail Resorts

A major resort operator that acquired Park City Mountain and is defending its right to operate the Timberline and Iron Mountain Express chairlifts.

UI Charitable Advisors

A Provo-based nonprofit that purchased a parcel of land within The Colony at White Pine Canyon in December 2024 and is now claiming Vail Resorts is trespassing on its land.

Summit County Third District Judge Richard Mrazik

The judge who will weigh the validity of the 2003 easement agreement against the nonprofit's new land ownership claim.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Vail Resorts' claims are unsupportable and without any reasonable reason.”

— UI Charitable Advisors

“These lifts are critical to the functioning of the resort.”

— Vail Resorts

What’s next

Judge Richard Mrazik will decide whether to dismiss the case brought by UI Charitable Advisors or uphold the nonprofit's claims against Vail Resorts' right to operate the Timberline and Iron Mountain Express chairlifts.

The takeaway

This legal battle highlights the complex web of land rights and easements that can underpin the operations of major ski resorts, with significant implications for the local economy, jobs, and property values if critical chairlifts are forced to shut down.