Judge Blocks Demolition of Camp Mystic Cabins After Deadly Flood

Ruling preserves potential evidence in wrongful death lawsuit over Texas youth camp safety violations.

Apr. 17, 2026 at 1:39pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An extreme close-up of a twisted, mud-caked cabin door handle reflecting the harsh light of a camera flash, conceptually illustrating the aftermath of the deadly flash flood at Camp Mystic.The preserved cabins at Camp Mystic stand as a cautionary emblem, their silent walls bearing witness to the failure of emergency protocols.Austin Today

A Texas judge has issued a preliminary injunction preventing Camp Mystic from altering or demolishing cabins where three girls died in a 2023 flash flood, ruling the site may constitute critical evidence in a wrongful death lawsuit alleging violations of state youth camp safety statutes. The order stems from a civil suit filed by the victims' families, who contend camp operators ignored flood warnings and failed to implement a written evacuation plan as required by law.

Why it matters

The judge's decision to block alterations at the Camp Mystic site is a stark reminder of systemic gaps in oversight that allowed this preventable tragedy to unfold. It directly impacts how youth recreational facilities across Texas manage liability, emergency preparedness, and compliance with state-mandated safety protocols.

The details

Investigations revealed Camp Mystic had received multiple flash flood alerts from the National Weather Service the morning of the incident but lacked a centralized, written protocol to evacuate campers to higher ground, as required by Texas law. The ruling to preserve the physical scene for forensic inspection is based on the legal doctrine of spoliation, preventing the destruction of evidence that could prove negligence.

  • On June 11, 2023, emergency responders arrived at Camp Mystic near Medina Lake to find cabins swept off their foundations and three girls, ages 9, 11, and 12, trapped in the wreckage.
  • On April 16, 2026, Judge Lina Hidalgo issued a preliminary injunction preventing Camp Mystic from altering or demolishing the cabins.

The players

Judge Lina Hidalgo

A Travis County district judge who issued the preliminary injunction preventing Camp Mystic from altering or demolishing the cabins where the incident occurred.

David Ruiz

A Texas State Bar-certified personal injury attorney who has consulted on similar youth camp litigation and explained the legal doctrine of spoliation behind the judge's decision.

Chris Schuchart

The Medina County Judge whose office oversees emergency management for the unincorporated areas where Camp Mystic operates, noting concerns about regulatory blind spots in youth camp oversight.

Texas Youth Camp Association

An advocacy group lobbying for legislation to strengthen the Texas Youth Camp Safety Act, including mandates for real-time weather monitoring, annual safety audits, and stricter penalties for lacking evacuation plans.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“In cases involving potential criminal or civil liability tied to institutional safety failures, preserving the scene is non-negotiable.”

— David Ruiz, Texas State Bar-certified personal injury attorney

“We depend on camps to police themselves, and that model failed here. After this incident, we pushed for annual on-site evaluations, but the legislature has yet to act. Until then, tragedies like this will keep happening in places where oversight is thin and accountability is reactive.”

— Chris Schuchart, Medina County Judge

What’s next

The judge's ruling to preserve the Camp Mystic site means the cabins and surrounding evidence will be available for forensic inspection as the wrongful death lawsuit proceeds through the discovery phase.

The takeaway

This incident has reignited calls to strengthen Texas' youth camp safety laws, which currently rely on self-reported documentation and infrequent state inspections. Until regulatory reforms are enacted, the burden falls on individual camp operators to exceed minimum standards and prioritize verifiable emergency preparedness measures that can prevent future tragedies.