Rhode Island Court Upholds Non-Renewal of 51 Providence Teacher Contracts

Superior Court rules education commissioner had authority to override school board vote.

Apr. 17, 2026 at 10:30pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A bold, colorful silkscreen-style illustration of a stack of teacher's grade books repeated in a grid, representing the tension over teacher employment decisions between state and local education officials.The Rhode Island Superior Court's ruling on teacher contract non-renewals highlights the ongoing power struggle between state and local education authorities.Providence Today

The Rhode Island Superior Court has upheld the state's education commissioner's decision to vacate a vote by the Providence School Board not to approve the superintendent's recommendation to not renew the teaching contracts of 51 non-tenured, probationary teachers for the 2024-2025 school year. The court ruled that state law gives the commissioner the authority to make final decisions on teacher selection and appointment, with the school board playing only an advisory role.

Why it matters

This case highlights the ongoing tension between state education authorities and local school boards over control of teacher employment decisions. The ruling affirms the commissioner's power to override local board decisions, which could have implications for teacher job security and school district autonomy.

The details

According to the court's 26-page decision, state statute G.L. §16-2-18 gives the commissioner the authority to approve the superintendent's recommendations for teacher selection and appointment, with the school board playing an advisory role. The judge ruled that the commissioner did not exceed her statutory powers by vacating the Providence School Board's vote not to approve the non-renewal of 51 probationary teacher contracts.

  • The Providence School Board voted not to approve the non-renewal of 51 teacher contracts in 2024.
  • The Rhode Island Commissioner of Education vacated the school board's vote later in 2024.
  • The Superior Court upheld the commissioner's decision in April 2026.

The players

Angelica Infante-Green

The Rhode Island Commissioner of Education who vacated the Providence School Board's vote on teacher contract non-renewals.

The Providence Teachers Union, Local 958

The union that filed the lawsuit challenging the commissioner's authority to override the school board's decision.

Judge Luis M. Matos

The Rhode Island Superior Court judge who ruled in favor of the commissioner's authority in this case.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“This language clearly and unambiguously provides express statutory support for the Hearing Officer's conclusion that the Board's role in the selection and appointment of teachers is advisory — the position the Commissioner has openly maintained since at least 2019.”

— Judge Luis M. Matos, Rhode Island Superior Court Judge

What’s next

The Providence Teachers Union may appeal the Superior Court's decision to a higher state court.

The takeaway

This case underscores the ongoing power struggle between state education authorities and local school boards over control of teacher employment decisions, with the ruling affirming the commissioner's ability to override local board decisions on contract non-renewals.