Providence Mayor Faces Rent Control Battle Ahead of Election

Smiley wants to build more housing, but rent control proposal divides city council

Apr. 16, 2026 at 12:08am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A serene, nostalgic painting of a multi-story apartment building in Providence, with warm sunlight casting long shadows across the facade and windows, conveying a sense of quiet contemplation about the city's ongoing housing challenges.As the debate over rent control intensifies, a sense of uncertainty looms over Providence's residential neighborhoods.Providence Today

Providence Mayor Brett Smiley is facing a political battle over rent control as he seeks reelection. Smiley opposes a rent control proposal from the city council, arguing it won't lower rents and will make the housing crisis worse. However, the council's progressive wing, led by Council President Rachel Miller, supports the rent control measure and plans to override Smiley's expected veto. The issue has become a key campaign promise for Smiley's challenger, Councilor John Morales, who says Smiley's housing plans don't do enough to prevent rent hikes.

Why it matters

The rent control debate is a high-stakes political issue that could make or break Smiley's reelection campaign. Rent control is a popular policy with voters, but Smiley argues it won't actually solve the underlying housing shortage. The outcome could have major implications for the city's approach to addressing the affordable housing crisis.

The details

Smiley has proposed a $636 million city budget that includes funding for emergency rent relief, eviction defense, and home repairs, as well as a $25 million housing bond. He has also touted efforts to streamline housing development and zoning. However, the council's rent control proposal, which needs a two-thirds majority to override Smiley's expected veto, has divided the council. Smiley says rent control 'doesn't provide rent relief to anyone' and will make the problem worse, while the council's progressive wing argues it is necessary to protect renters.

  • On Wednesday, Smiley gave his annual state of the city address, which typically serves as a chance for mayors to pitch their plans to voters in an election year.
  • The city council tabled Smiley's budget proposal on Wednesday night, instead of sending it to the Finance Committee as usual.

The players

Brett Smiley

The mayor of Providence, Rhode Island, who is seeking reelection and opposes a rent control proposal from the city council.

Rachel Miller

The president of the Providence City Council, who leads the council's progressive wing and supports the rent control measure.

John Morales

A Providence city councilor who is challenging Smiley in the mayoral election and has made capping rent increases a key campaign promise.

Jo-Ann Ryan

The chair of the city council's Finance Committee, who is an ally of Smiley and has said she will not change her 'no' vote on rent stabilization.

Providence City Council

The all-Democratic city council, which is divided on the rent control issue and needs a two-thirds majority to override Smiley's expected veto.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“'I think rent control is actually going to make the problem worse and not better. It doesn't provide rent relief to anyone. It doesn't lower anyone's rent.'”

— Brett Smiley, Mayor of Providence

“'Tomorrow we're going to make history in the city of Providence. The council's going to stand up for renters.'”

— Rachel Miller, Providence City Council President

“'The cost of rent in Providence is too high, and we know it will not meaningfully lower until we address the underlying cause of this crisis: the housing shortage. Providence needs to build more homes.'”

— Brett Smiley, Mayor of Providence

What’s next

The Providence City Council is expected to vote on the rent control proposal on Thursday, where it will need a two-thirds majority to override Smiley's expected veto. The outcome of this vote could have major implications for Smiley's reelection campaign.

The takeaway

The battle over rent control in Providence has become a high-stakes political issue that pits the mayor against the city council's progressive wing. Smiley argues rent control won't solve the housing crisis, while the council says it's necessary to protect renters. The outcome could determine the direction of the city's affordable housing policies and Smiley's political future.