Steelers Seek AFC North-Style QB in 2024 NFL Draft

Penn State's Drew Allar emerges as top option to lead Pittsburgh into the future

Apr. 12, 2026 at 6:39am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A cubist, geometric painting depicting a football player in motion, with the figure broken down into sharp, overlapping planes of color, capturing the raw energy and physicality of the sport.The Steelers' search for an 'AFC North-style' quarterback reflects the unique challenges of the division, where physical toughness and resilience are essential.Today in Pittsburgh

As the Pittsburgh Steelers search for their next franchise quarterback, they are prioritizing a player who can thrive in the harsh winter conditions of the AFC North division. With the arrival of new head coach Mike McCarthy, the team is looking for a strong-armed passer with the physical attributes to excel in the cold, leading them to consider Penn State's Drew Allar as a potential third-round pick.

Why it matters

The Steelers' quarterback search is crucial for the team's long-term success, as they aim to find a successor to the legendary Ben Roethlisberger. McCarthy's emphasis on an 'AFC North-style' quarterback reflects the unique challenges of the division, where teams must be able to win tough, physical games in inclement weather.

The details

Allar, a native of Ohio, possesses the size and arm strength that McCarthy desires, with the third-biggest hands and second-longest arms of any quarterback at the combine. ESPN draft analyst Mel Kiper praised Allar's throwing ability, suggesting he could be a top-three quarterback taken. However, Allar's inconsistent performance in big games has raised concerns, and the Steelers may see him as their best option with the top quarterback, Fernando Mendoza, already off the board.

  • The 2024 NFL Draft is scheduled for April.
  • The Steelers are currently in the process of evaluating quarterback prospects for the upcoming draft.

The players

Drew Allar

A quarterback prospect from Penn State, known for his size and arm strength, which make him a potential fit for the Steelers' 'AFC North-style' quarterback search.

Mike McCarthy

The new head coach of the Pittsburgh Steelers, who has emphasized the importance of finding a quarterback who can thrive in the harsh winter conditions of the AFC North division.

Ben Roethlisberger

The legendary former quarterback of the Pittsburgh Steelers, whose success in the AFC North has set a high bar for the team's next signal-caller.

Fernando Mendoza

The top quarterback prospect in the 2024 NFL Draft, who is already off the board, leaving the Steelers to consider other options like Drew Allar.

Ty Simpson

Another quarterback prospect in the 2024 NFL Draft, but one who may not fit the 'AFC North-style' that the Steelers are seeking due to his smaller stature and limited starting experience.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“We must find a quarterback who can perform in the cold and thrive in the tough conditions of the AFC North. That's the type of player we're looking for.”

— Mike McCarthy, Head Coach, Pittsburgh Steelers

“Drew Allar has the physical tools to be a successful quarterback in the NFL, with his arm strength and size being particularly appealing. He could be a potential third-round pick.”

— Mel Kiper, ESPN Draft Analyst

“Ty Simpson's limited starting experience is a concern, but his background as the son of a coach could be an advantage as teams get to know him better.”

— Daniel Jeremiah, NFL Network Analyst

What’s next

The Steelers will continue to evaluate quarterback prospects in the lead-up to the 2024 NFL Draft, with a focus on finding a player who can thrive in the harsh conditions of the AFC North division.

The takeaway

The Steelers' search for their next franchise quarterback reflects the unique challenges of the AFC North, where teams must be able to win tough, physical games in inclement weather. Drew Allar's physical attributes make him a potential fit, but his inconsistent performance in big games could be a concern for the team as they look to find the right player to lead them into the future.