Colts' Pittman Jr. Emerges as Top Bills Offseason Target

NFL commentator Nate Geary declares Indy WR as perfect fit for Buffalo's receiving corps

Published on Feb. 20, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

According to NFL commentator Nate Geary, the Buffalo Bills' top offseason target should be Indianapolis Colts wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr. Geary believes Pittman Jr. would be a perfect fit for the Bills, citing his ability to play both outside and in the slot, his young age, and his flashes of dominance. The Colts may be willing to part with Pittman Jr. if they can get the right trade package, with one potential deal involving the Carolina Panthers.

Why it matters

The Bills are in need of bolstering their receiving corps to continue maximizing quarterback Josh Allen's MVP-caliber talents. Pittman Jr. could provide the boundary and versatile threat the Bills are seeking to elevate their passing attack.

The details

Nate Geary, the host of the WGR 550 Overtime Show, has declared that the Bills should pursue Pittman Jr. this offseason. Pittman Jr. is still under contract with the Colts, but The Athletic's James Boyd mentioned him as a potential cap casualty. Geary believes Pittman Jr. "fits the Bills perfectly" with his ability to play both outside and in the slot, his young age, and his flashes of dominance. Over the past two seasons, Pittman Jr. has seen a dip in production, recording just 1,592 yards receiving. However, he did find the end zone seven times in 2025. The Colts may be willing to trade Pittman Jr. and eat some of his sizable cap hit, with one potential deal involving the Carolina Panthers.

  • Pittman Jr. is currently under contract with the Indianapolis Colts.
  • The Colts may release or trade Pittman Jr. this offseason due to his $29 million cap hit in 2026.

The players

Michael Pittman Jr.

An Indianapolis Colts wide receiver who has emerged as a potential top offseason target for the Buffalo Bills.

Nate Geary

The host of the WGR 550 Overtime Show, who has declared Pittman Jr. as the Bills' top offseason target.

Josh Allen

The Buffalo Bills' star quarterback who could benefit from the addition of a versatile wide receiver like Pittman Jr.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“He's my number one target IMO. He fits the bill perfect. Boundary guy who can bump inside. Still young. Flashes on dominance.”

— Nate Geary, Host, WGR 550 Overtime Show (X)

What’s next

The Colts will have to decide whether to release, trade, or restructure Pittman Jr.'s contract this offseason. If he becomes available, the Bills will likely pursue him to bolster their receiving corps.

The takeaway

The Bills' pursuit of Pittman Jr. highlights their need to surround quarterback Josh Allen with more dynamic receiving threats. Acquiring a versatile, young wideout like Pittman Jr. could help the Bills' offense reach new heights and continue their quest for a Super Bowl championship.