Gettysburg ex-mayor charged with child sex crimes, organizations he founded struggle

The former mayor's arrest has left the Gettysburg Community Theatre and Gettysburg Pride without access to critical resources and leadership.

Mar. 19, 2026 at 9:20am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Chad-Alan Carr, the former mayor of Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, has been charged with child sex crimes. Carr was the founding executive artistic director of the Gettysburg Community Theatre and the co-founder of Gettysburg Pride. With Carr's sudden departure, the organizations he led are now facing significant challenges as they try to rebuild trust and continue their operations without access to crucial resources and leadership.

Why it matters

The arrest of a prominent community leader on child sex crime charges has sent shockwaves through Gettysburg. The organizations Carr founded are now struggling to recover, highlighting the risks of having a single individual hold too much control and the importance of building sustainable, community-driven institutions.

The details

Carr faces allegations that he groomed a teenage boy, exchanging nude photos and engaging in explicit video calls with him more than 10 years ago. With Carr's resignation and arrest, the Gettysburg Community Theatre and Gettysburg Pride have found themselves without access to their social media pages, contact lists, permits, and tens of thousands of dollars in funds, all of which Carr had sole control over. The organizations are now working to rebuild their operations and regain the trust of the community they serve.

  • Carr announced his resignation as mayor of Gettysburg on March 5, 2026.
  • Carr was charged with child sex crimes shortly after his resignation.
  • A special meeting of the Gettysburg Borough Council is scheduled for March 18, 2026, to choose a new mayor.

The players

Chad-Alan Carr

The former mayor of Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, who was the founding executive artistic director of the Gettysburg Community Theatre and the co-founder of Gettysburg Pride.

Matthew Moon

The Gettysburg Borough Council President and acting mayor.

Gettysburg Community Theatre

A local theater company that Carr founded in 2009 and served as the executive artistic director.

Gettysburg Pride

A gay-support organization that Carr co-founded in 2017.

Gettysburg School District

The school district that Carr worked with in a contractual role from 2010 to 2013, managing fall and spring productions.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“It is a challenging moment we all find ourselves in here. When an organization like this is very top heavy and it is centered on one person, that one person can disappear and the entire event suffers.”

— Matthew Moon, Gettysburg Borough Council President

“The Gettysburg LGBTQ+ community and its many allies are coming together in the wake of recent events, and the support has been heartening.”

— Florence March, Gettysburg Pride volunteer

“Chad ran the theater. He ran every aspect of the theater. We were in a quandary. How do we get on Facebook? How do we get on the website?”

— Scott Hartwig, President of the Gettysburg Community Theatre board

What’s next

The Gettysburg Borough Council will choose a new mayor at a special meeting on March 18, 2026. Carr's preliminary hearing on the child sex crime charges is scheduled for March 22, 2026.

The takeaway

The downfall of a prominent community leader has left the organizations he founded in a precarious position, highlighting the importance of building sustainable, community-driven institutions with shared leadership and clear succession plans. This case underscores the need for robust safeguards and oversight to protect vulnerable individuals, especially in organizations that work with children.