Sheriff: DNA Evidence Found in Guthrie Case

Investigators discover unknown DNA at crime scene and recovered gloves miles away

Published on Feb. 14, 2026

Authorities in Guthrie, Oklahoma have revealed that they have found DNA evidence at the home of Nancy Guthrie that does not belong to her or anyone close to her. The DNA is currently being tested, along with several gloves that were discovered up to 10 miles away from the residence. Officials are hopeful the new forensic evidence will provide critical clues to help solve the case.

Why it matters

The discovery of unidentified DNA at the crime scene and the recovery of potential evidence miles away from the home suggest the investigation may be entering a new phase. Forensic analysis of the DNA and gloves could potentially lead to a breakthrough in the case, which has remained unsolved for some time.

The details

Investigators stated they found DNA at Nancy Guthrie's house that does not match her or anyone close to her. The unknown DNA samples, as well as several gloves discovered as far as 10 miles from the residence, are currently undergoing forensic testing in the hopes of providing new leads in the case.

  • The DNA and gloves were discovered during the ongoing investigation into Nancy Guthrie's case.

The players

Nancy Guthrie

The victim in the unsolved case that authorities are investigating.

Guthrie Sheriff's Office

The law enforcement agency leading the investigation into Nancy Guthrie's case.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“We have DNA that doesn't belong to Nancy or anyone close to her, and we're testing it along with some gloves found miles away from the house.”

— Guthrie Sheriff

What’s next

The sheriff's office stated the DNA and glove evidence is currently being analyzed, and they are hopeful the forensic testing will provide new leads to help solve the case.

The takeaway

The discovery of unidentified DNA and recovered evidence miles from the crime scene suggests the investigation may be entering a critical new phase, as authorities work to uncover the truth behind Nancy Guthrie's unsolved case.