Oklahoma Shop's Key Lime Pie Draws Loyal Fans From Hours Away

Railyard Pie Company's tart, creamy key lime pie has developed a cult following, with customers driving across state lines just for a slice.

Apr. 17, 2026 at 2:00am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A vibrant, high-contrast silkscreen print featuring a single slice of key lime pie repeated in a grid pattern, rendered in bold, neon-inspired colors and heavy black outlines to capture the iconic status of this beloved Oklahoma dessert.Railyard Pie Company's signature key lime pie has developed a cult following, with customers driving hours just to get a slice of the tart, creamy dessert.Edmond Today

In the unassuming town of Edmond, Oklahoma, a small shop called Railyard Pie Company has become a destination for its exceptional key lime pie. People are driving hours just to get a taste of the tart, creamy filling in the buttery graham cracker crust. The shop's cozy, welcoming atmosphere and attention to detail in every item on the menu have turned it into a local institution.

Why it matters

In an era of mass-produced, generic baked goods, Railyard Pie Company stands out as a shining example of a small, independent business that has built a loyal following by focusing on quality, craftsmanship, and an authentic connection to its community. The shop's success highlights the enduring appeal of artisanal, locally-sourced food and the power of word-of-mouth to drive customers to a hidden gem.

The details

Railyard Pie Company is located in a repurposed building in the heart of Edmond's lively Railyard district, giving it a cozy, inviting atmosphere. The open kitchen allows customers to watch the bakers at work, adding to the personal, homemade feel. The key lime pie features a buttery, flaky crust that perfectly complements the tart, creamy filling. Customers rave about the balance of flavors and the attention to detail in every slice. The shop also offers a variety of savory options, like quiche and salads, making it a versatile destination for any time of day.

  • Railyard Pie Company opened in 2015.
  • The key lime pie has been a menu staple since the beginning, drawing in customers from across Oklahoma and beyond.

The players

Railyard Pie Company

A small, independent bakery located in Edmond, Oklahoma, known for its exceptional key lime pie and other homemade baked goods.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“The key lime pie here is the best I've ever had. The crust is flaky and buttery, and the filling is the perfect balance of tart and creamy.”

— Sarah Thompson, Edmond resident

“I've driven over three hours just to get a slice of Railyard's key lime pie. It's worth every minute in the car.”

— Jenna Rodriguez, Pie enthusiast

What’s next

Railyard Pie Company plans to expand its seasonal offerings, with new flavors and specials rotating throughout the year to keep customers coming back.

The takeaway

Railyard Pie Company's success is a testament to the power of quality, craftsmanship, and a genuine connection to the local community. In an age of mass-produced baked goods, this small-town shop has built a loyal following by focusing on perfecting a single signature item - its exceptional key lime pie.