Guardians' Rookies Shine Early, But Bullpen Woes Loom

Examining the Guardians' promising start and emerging challenges in the young MLB season.

Apr. 18, 2026 at 4:35pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A fractured, multi-perspective painting depicting the dynamic action of a Guardians baseball game, with the players and field broken down into sharp, overlapping geometric shapes in a vibrant color palette.The Guardians' young roster and low payroll have them punching above their weight in the early season, but key questions remain about the bullpen and infield.Cleveland Today

The Cleveland Guardians have gotten off to an 11-10 start in the 2026 season, led by impressive performances from their rookie players like Parker Messick, Chase DeLauter, and Juan Brito. However, the team is facing early bullpen concerns with closer Cade Smith struggling to replace the departed Emmanuel Clase. The Guardians' low payroll compared to their opponents has also been a talking point, as the team continues its 'David vs. Goliath' act in the AL Central.

Why it matters

The Guardians' early-season success with their young talent is an encouraging sign for the franchise's future, but the team's bullpen issues and financial constraints could hinder their ability to compete in the tough AL Central division. How the rookies develop and the bullpen stabilizes will be crucial factors in determining if the Guardians can maintain their winning ways.

The details

The Guardians are carrying five rookies on their 26-man roster, led by left-hander Parker Messick, who has been dominant in his first four starts. Outfielder Chase DeLauter had a hot start but has cooled off, while second baseman Juan Brito has struggled after a strong debut. The bullpen, without closer Emmanuel Clase, has been a concern, with Cade Smith and others already among the MLB leaders in appearances. The Guardians' payroll of $70 million is the lowest in baseball, putting them at a disadvantage against teams with much higher payrolls.

  • The Guardians have played 21 games so far this season.
  • On Friday, the Guardians lost 6-4 to the Orioles.
  • Closer Cade Smith is already among the MLB leaders in appearances.

The players

Parker Messick

A left-handed rookie pitcher who is 3-0 with a 1.05 ERA in his first four starts, dazzling against top teams like the Dodgers, Cubs, Braves, and Orioles.

Chase DeLauter

A rookie outfielder who had a hot start to the season, hitting .353 with four homers and six RBIs in his first four games, but has since struggled, hitting .208 with one homer and seven RBIs.

Juan Brito

A rookie second baseman who had four hits in his first two games but has gone 2-for-26 since, with inconsistent defense.

Cade Smith

The Guardians' new closer, replacing the departed Emmanuel Clase, who has been shaky in the role so far.

Emmanuel Clase

The Guardians' former All-Star closer, who is facing a trial in October on allegations of fixing pitches during games and is not expected to pitch this year.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Vogt will take 26 more starts just like the first four.”

— Paul Hoynes, Writer

“Their David vs. Goliath act is admirable, but it is of their own choosing. Ownership and the front office could do things differently if they wished.”

— Paul Hoynes, Writer

What’s next

When shortstop Gabriel Arias returns from injury, the Guardians will have to decide whether to keep Juan Brito on the roster or send him back to Triple-A Columbus. The team will also need to determine the long-term plan at second base and catcher as they continue to develop their young talent.

The takeaway

The Guardians' early-season success with their rookie players is an encouraging sign, but the team's bullpen issues and financial constraints could limit their ability to maintain their winning ways in the competitive AL Central. How the young talent develops and the team addresses its roster challenges will be crucial factors in determining the Guardians' fate this season.