Rochester's New Ice Cream Shop Brings Flavor and Community

Ice Cream Plus, a Black-owned family business, opens on East Main Street near Rochester's theater district.

Apr. 13, 2026 at 3:28am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A bold, vibrant silkscreen print of a single, iconic ice cream cone repeated in a tight grid pattern, using flat, neon colors and heavy black outlines to transform the everyday object into a modern pop art piece.A new family-owned ice cream shop in Rochester's theater district aims to be more than just a dessert destination, integrating into the community and curating a cultural experience.Rochester Today

A new ice cream shop called Ice Cream Plus has opened on East Main Street in Rochester, just steps from the city's bustling theater row. The shop is more than just a dessert destination - it's a statement about community, ownership, and the way small businesses can carve out a distinctive, local flavor in an urban area. Owned by the Evans family, Ice Cream Plus offers a mix of classic Hershey's soft serve and unique flavors, while also serving as a gathering place for residents and theater-goers alike.

Why it matters

The opening of Ice Cream Plus represents the integration of a Black-owned family business into a neighborhood that thrives on foot traffic from nearby theaters. This signals a broader trend of entertainment districts becoming multi-faceted hubs where culture, food, and commerce co-create a daily experience for the community. The shop's intentional focus on generational ownership and community ties also provides a narrative that customers can invest in beyond just the product.

The details

Ice Cream Plus offers a familiar lineup of cones, waffle cones, milkshakes, sundaes, and banana splits, anchored by Hershey's soft serve. But the shop also features soft serve from Upstate Farms, showcasing a deliberate balance between nostalgia and accessibility. The walk-up window design is a strategic choice to invite spontaneous stops and create shared moments of delight for passersby. With a patio on the horizon, Ice Cream Plus is also poised to extend its role from a quick stop to a social gathering place.

  • Ice Cream Plus opened in April 2026 on East Main Street in Rochester, New York.
  • Construction is underway on a new patio space for the shop.

The players

Gail Evans

The owner of Ice Cream Plus, part of a multi-generational family business.

Ice Cream Plus

A new ice cream shop that opened in 2026 on East Main Street in Rochester, New York, near the city's theater district.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Ice Cream Plus isn't just about scoops; it's a statement about community, ownership, and the way small businesses can carve out a distinctive, local flavor in a city that loves its seats and stage lights.”

— Author

What’s next

With construction underway on a new patio space, Ice Cream Plus is poised to expand its role from a quick dessert stop to a social gathering place for the community.

The takeaway

The opening of Ice Cream Plus represents more than just a new ice cream shop - it's a case study in community entrepreneurship, strategic location, and cultural storytelling. The shop's focus on generational ownership, representation, and integration into the local theater district signals a broader trend of retail and hospitality becoming experiential ecosystems that curate experiences, identities, and conversations beyond just the products they sell.