Rock Stars Disown These 3 'Bad' Songs, But I'll Defend Them

These tunes may be considered duds, but they still have something special to offer.

Apr. 18, 2026 at 3:09pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An extreme close-up photograph of shattered, glittering glass fragments reflecting dramatic studio lighting, conveying the conceptual idea of the hidden flaws and 'bad' songs beneath the surface of rock star perfection.The glittering textures and dramatic lighting of rock star glamour can sometimes mask the imperfections beneath the surface.NYC Today

While rock stars like Bruce Springsteen, Paul McCartney, and the Eagles' Glenn Frey and Don Henley have openly criticized and distanced themselves from certain songs in their catalogs, the author argues that these 'bad' tunes actually have redeeming qualities worth appreciating.

Why it matters

Even the most acclaimed artists can produce songs that don't live up to their usual standards, but sometimes those 'bad' tracks still have something unique or endearing about them that's worth a closer listen, beyond the artists' own dismissals.

The details

The author defends three songs that the original artists have openly criticized or disowned: Bruce Springsteen's 'Lucky Town' from his 1992 album of the same name, The Beatles' 'Hold Me Tight' from their 1963 album With The Beatles, and the Eagles' 'Earlybird' from their 1972 self-titled debut. While the artists themselves have called these songs 'failed singles,' 'corny,' or otherwise duds, the author finds redeeming qualities in each, from Springsteen's virtuosic guitar work to the youthful energy of The Beatles' track to the charming campiness of the Eagles' tune.

  • Springsteen acknowledged disliking the 'happy and fulfilled' era of his career in his 1999 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction speech.
  • The Beatles released 'Hold Me Tight' in 1963 on their With The Beatles album.
  • The Eagles released their self-titled debut album, including 'Earlybird,' in 1972.

The players

Bruce Springsteen

A legendary singer-songwriter known for his working-class anthems and heartland rock sound, though he has distanced himself from the more upbeat, domestic-themed material on his 1992 album 'Lucky Town.'

Paul McCartney

The iconic singer, songwriter, and bassist of The Beatles, who has described the band's early song 'Hold Me Tight' as a 'failed single' that he has little emotional attachment to.

Glenn Frey

The co-founder and guitarist of the Eagles, known for the band's meticulous, perfectionistic approach to songwriting, though he and bandmate Don Henley have dismissed the silliness of the song 'Earlybird' from the Eagles' debut album.

Don Henley

The co-founder, drummer, and vocalist of the Eagles, who has called the song 'Earlybird' from the band's debut album 'corny.'

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Not many fans loved that era of his career in which he wrote songs about being happy and fulfilled, with some domestic bliss mixed in.”

— Bruce Springsteen

“It's a failed single. I don't have much emotional memory tied to it.”

— Paul McCartney

“It's corny.”

— Don Henley

The takeaway

Even the most acclaimed artists can produce songs that don't live up to their usual standards, but sometimes those 'bad' tracks still have something unique or endearing about them that's worth a closer listen, beyond the artists' own dismissals.