Boebert Breaks with GOP on Spy Law, Defends 4th Amendment

The Colorado congresswoman argues the government should not be able to purchase Americans' private data without a warrant.

Apr. 16, 2026 at 9:39pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A dynamic, abstract painting of a fractured, geometric government surveillance drone or satellite in shades of dark blue, grey, and black, conveying the complex and contested nature of digital privacy and security.Boebert's challenge to warrantless government surveillance reflects growing bipartisan concerns over the balance between national security and civil liberties.NYC Today

Rep. Lauren Boebert (R-CO) has broken with House Republican leadership over the reauthorization of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA), arguing the government should not be able to purchase Americans' private data without a warrant. Boebert's stance puts her in rare alignment with progressive lawmakers like Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), who have criticized FISA as a "constitutional crisis" that violates civil rights.

Why it matters

Boebert's opposition to the so-called "data broker loophole" in FISA highlights a growing bipartisan concern over warrantless government surveillance of Americans' digital lives. Her stance challenges the push by the White House and House GOP leadership for a clean 18-month extension of the law without reforms.

The details

Boebert told reporters she wants to ensure "the Fourth Amendment is not for sale" and that the federal government should not be able to "purchase American citizens' data from private companies" as a "workaround" to obtaining warrants. More than 50 House Democrats have joined the push to include Fourth Amendment protections in the FISA reauthorization.

  • FISA Section 702 is set to expire on April 20, 2026 unless extended by Congress.
  • The House Rules Committee has approved a closed rule blocking a warrant amendment from coming to a floor vote.

The players

Rep. Lauren Boebert

A Republican congresswoman from Colorado who has broken with her party's leadership over FISA reauthorization, arguing the government should not be able to purchase Americans' private data without a warrant.

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez

A Democratic congresswoman from New York who has criticized FISA as a "constitutional crisis" that violates civil rights, aligning her with Boebert's position.

House Speaker Mike Johnson

The Republican House Speaker who has pushed for a clean 18-month extension of FISA with no reforms attached.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“I want the Fourth Amendment to not be for sale. The federal government should not be able to purchase American citizens' data from private companies. This is a complete violation — it's a workaround from any kind of warrants and looking into Americans' lives.”

— Rep. Lauren Boebert

“We've had a huge amount of problems with warrantless surveillance wiretapping against American civilians. [FISA] has been a constitutional crisis since its drafting.”

— Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez

What’s next

The House is expected to vote on the FISA reauthorization bill in the coming days, with the outcome uncertain as lawmakers like Boebert push for Fourth Amendment protections.

The takeaway

Boebert's break with GOP leadership on FISA highlights growing bipartisan concerns over warrantless government surveillance and the need to balance national security with civil liberties. Her stance could influence the final shape of the reauthorization bill.