NYC Council Speaker, Mayor Reach Truce Over Key Appointment

Menin agrees to support Mamdani's pick for Department of Investigation after tense standoff

Apr. 15, 2026 at 7:07pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A dimly lit, cinematic painting of an empty New York City Council chamber, with sunlight streaming in through tall windows and casting long shadows across the ornate wooden desks and chairs, conveying a sense of quiet contemplation and political drama.The truce between New York's mayor and City Council speaker reflects a temporary de-escalation of political tensions, though their broader policy disagreements remain.NYC Today

After a months-long feud, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and City Council Speaker Julie Menin have reached a truce over the mayor's nomination of Nadia Shihata to lead the city's Department of Investigation. Menin had initially expressed concerns about Shihata's independence and ties to the mayor, but has now agreed to support the nomination following a private phone call between the two leaders.

Why it matters

The standoff between the mayor and council speaker had escalated in recent months, with the two skipping their regular weekly meetings. Menin's decision to block Shihata's appointment would have been a significant political blow to Mamdani. The truce represents a de-escalation of tensions and a willingness to work together on key appointments, even amid their broader policy disagreements.

The details

Menin and many City Council members had grilled Shihata during a recent confirmation hearing, focusing on her $700 in campaign donations to Mamdani and her friendship with the mayor's chief counsel. These concerns were aired during a private meeting of Council members. However, after speaking with Mamdani, Menin said she had overcome her reservations and would support Shihata's nomination, citing the nominee's qualifications and commitment to independent leadership.

  • The mayor and council speaker have been feuding for the past three months.
  • Menin was considering blocking Shihata's appointment as head of the Department of Investigation.
  • Menin and Mamdani spoke by phone on Tuesday night and reached a truce.
  • Shihata's nomination is scheduled for a Council vote on Thursday.

The players

Zohran Mamdani

The mayor of New York City who nominated Nadia Shihata to lead the Department of Investigation.

Julie Menin

The speaker of the New York City Council who initially expressed concerns about Shihata's nomination but has now agreed to support it.

Nadia Shihata

Mamdani's nominee to lead the Department of Investigation, a former federal prosecutor.

Ramzi Kassem

The mayor's chief counsel, who had a friendship with Shihata that raised concerns among some City Council members.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“After careful review, Speaker Menin is supporting Nadia Shihata's nomination, based on her qualifications and her stated commitment to independent leadership. Rooting out corruption and fraud in government is a top priority for the speaker and she believes Ms. Shihata's 11 years as a prosecutor in New York's Eastern District makes her well positioned to take on that fight head on.”

— Yoav Gonen, Spokesman for Speaker Menin

What’s next

Shihata's nomination is scheduled for a vote by the full City Council on Thursday.

The takeaway

The truce between Mayor Mamdani and Council Speaker Menin represents a de-escalation of political tensions in New York City, at least on the issue of key mayoral appointments. However, the broader policy disagreements between the two leaders remain, and their ability to work together on other issues will be closely watched.