Traitors Reunion Erupts in Chaos as Villain Colton Underwood Targeted by Furious Co-Stars

The Traitors reunion taping descended into a 'full-blown reality TV war zone' with host Andy Cohen struggling to regain control, according to an insider.

Published on Feb. 17, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The Traitors reunion for Season 4 turned into the 'most dramatic' and 'chaotic' taping in the show's history, with former Bachelor star Colton Underwood being heavily targeted by his co-stars. Bravo veterans Candiace Dillard Bassett and Lisa Rinna were said to be 'leading the charge with drama, being loud, yelling, going for it, being shady.' The atmosphere quickly spiraled into chaos, with some contestants too nervous to speak up for fear of being yelled at. Colton was reportedly left 'not on good terms' with several other contestants, and the insider believes viewers won't like him any better after seeing the reunion.

Why it matters

The Traitors reunion's chaotic nature highlights the intense drama and personal conflicts that can arise when bringing together a diverse cast of reality TV stars with strong personalities. The targeting of Colton Underwood, in particular, reflects the ongoing scrutiny and backlash he has faced over his past controversies, which have continued to follow him even as he tries to move forward with his career.

The details

According to the insider, the reunion taping descended into a 'full-blown reality TV war zone,' with Colton Underwood and fellow contestant Rob Rausch being the main targets. While people generally like Rob as a person, many do not like Colton, leading to a very personal and heated dynamic. Bravo veterans Candiace Dillard Bassett and Lisa Rinna were said to be 'leading the charge with drama, being loud, yelling, going for it, being shady,' leaving some of the other, non-Bravo contestants too nervous to speak up. The chaos also included contestant Michael Rapaport repeatedly inserting himself into arguments and making the exchanges even more fiery, much to the frustration of host Andy Cohen.

  • The Traitors Season 4 reunion was taped in early 2026.

The players

Colton Underwood

A former NFL player and lead of The Bachelor who has faced ongoing scrutiny and backlash over his past controversies, including a restraining order filed by his ex-girlfriend Cassie Randolph.

Rob Rausch

A popular contestant from Love Island USA known for his charm and good looks.

Candiace Dillard Bassett

A former cast member of The Real Housewives of Potomac, known for her explosive reunion moments.

Lisa Rinna

A veteran of The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills, also known for her dramatic reunion appearances.

Michael Rapaport

An actor and comedian who repeatedly inserted himself into arguments during the reunion taping, further escalating the chaos.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

The takeaway

The chaotic Traitors reunion highlights the intense personal conflicts and drama that can arise when bringing together a diverse cast of reality TV stars with strong personalities. The targeting of Colton Underwood in particular reflects the ongoing scrutiny he faces over his past controversies, which continue to follow him even as he tries to move forward with his career.