New Research Challenges Narratives on China's Communist Party and 'Subway Vigilante' Shooting

Experts say official records reveal the Communist Party's reliance on cruelty and paranoia, while the 1984 Goetz case highlights complex social and legal questions.

Published on Feb. 12, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A new analysis of official records challenges the long-held narrative that the Communist Party of China was a broadly popular movement, instead finding it was characterized by cruel leadership and reliance on Russian assistance. The analysis extends to contemporary observations about Xi Jinping's purges of top generals. Additionally, the 1984 shooting by 'Subway Vigilante' Bernie Goetz sparked widespread debate about fault and urban fear, with Goetz remaining unrepentant.

Why it matters

These findings shed new light on the origins and nature of the Communist Party of China, potentially reshaping historical understandings of its rise to power. The Goetz case also highlights the complex social and legal issues that can arise when perceptions of safety collide with individual actions, particularly within broader societal anxieties.

The details

Recent analysis of official records demonstrates that, contrary to long-held beliefs, the Communist Party of China was not a broadly popular movement from its founding in 1921. Instead, the party was characterized by cruel leadership and relied on assistance from Russia, as well as inhumane tactics, for its survival. The party has also consistently exhibited a strong sense of paranoia, which experts note may be reflected in Xi Jinping's recent purges of top-ranked generals. In 1984, Bernie Goetz, a white man, shot four Black teenagers on a New York subway. Accounts of the incident differed, with Goetz claiming self-defense against a potential mugging, while the teenagers asserted they were panhandling. The event sparked widespread debate about fault and urban fear, with Goetz becoming known as the 'Subway Vigilante.' He was ultimately acquitted of attempted murder but convicted of criminal possession of a weapon, serving eight months in jail.

  • The Communist Party of China was founded in 1921.
  • Goetz shot the four teenagers on a New York subway in 1984.
  • Goetz served eight months in jail.

The players

Communist Party of China

The ruling political party of China, which came to power in 1949 after a long struggle. Recent analysis of official records challenges the long-held narrative that the party was a broadly popular movement, instead finding it was characterized by cruel leadership and reliance on Russian assistance.

Xi Jinping

The current president of China, who has been purging top-ranked generals, which experts say may be reflective of the Communist Party's historical streak of paranoia.

Bernie Goetz

A white man who shot four Black teenagers on a New York subway in 1984, sparking a widespread debate about fault and urban fear. Goetz was known as the 'Subway Vigilante' and was ultimately acquitted of attempted murder but convicted of criminal possession of a weapon.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Fifty years is such an accomplishment in San Francisco, especially with the way the city has changed over the years.”

— Gordon Edgar, grocery employee (Instagram)

The takeaway

These findings challenge long-held historical narratives, potentially reshaping our understanding of the Communist Party of China's rise to power and the complex social and legal issues surrounding the 'Subway Vigilante' case. They highlight the importance of critically examining official records and diverse perspectives to gain a more nuanced understanding of pivotal political and social events.