Clarkstown Appoints New Police Chief, Effective April 2026

Capt. James S. Fay, Jr. to succeed retiring Chief Jeffrey Wanamaker after 39-year career

Apr. 11, 2026 at 12:35pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An extreme close-up photograph of a police badge or insignia, dramatically lit by a harsh, direct camera flash against a pitch-black background, conveying a sense of authority, investigation, and change.The appointment of a new police chief signals a critical transition for the Clarkstown community, with high expectations for the department's future leadership.New City Today

Supervisor George Hoehmann and the Clarkstown Town Board have appointed Capt. James S. Fay, Jr. as the next Chief of Police for the Town of Clarkstown, effective April 24, 2026. Fay will succeed Chief Jeffrey Wanamaker, who is retiring after an impressive 39-year career with the Clarkstown Police Department.

Why it matters

The appointment of a new police chief is a significant event for the Clarkstown community, as the chief plays a crucial role in setting the department's priorities, policies, and approach to public safety. Fay's extensive experience within the department, including leadership roles in specialized units and emergency response, suggests he is well-prepared to take on this important position.

The details

Capt. Fay brings 32 years of experience within the Clarkstown Police Department, with a career spanning both operational and administrative leadership. He has served in specialized units such as narcotics and organized crime investigations, the Juvenile Aid Bureau, and the Critical Incident Response Team. Fay has also held leadership roles overseeing patrol operations, field training, and special operations.

  • Capt. Fay will assume the role of Police Chief on April 24, 2026.
  • Chief Wanamaker is retiring after 39 years with the Clarkstown Police Department, including serving as Chief since 2021.

The players

George Hoehmann

Clarkstown Town Supervisor.

James S. Fay, Jr.

Capt. James S. Fay, Jr. is the incoming Police Chief for the Town of Clarkstown, with 32 years of experience within the department.

Jeffrey Wanamaker

Retiring Police Chief of the Clarkstown Police Department, with a 39-year career.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Supervisor Hoehmann praised both leaders, expressing gratitude to Chief Wanamaker for his decades of service and confidence in Fay as a 'true public servant' committed to the department and community.”

— George Hoehmann, Clarkstown Town Supervisor

The takeaway

The appointment of Capt. James S. Fay, Jr. as the new Clarkstown Police Chief represents a smooth transition of leadership, with Fay's extensive experience and commitment to the department and community poised to build upon the strong foundation laid by the retiring Chief Wanamaker.