Fayetteville Colonial Built in 1931 Offers Timeless Elegance

This 1931 home designed by renowned architect Charles Umbrecht provides the perfect family retreat with modern comforts and historic charm.

Apr. 12, 2026 at 5:55pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A brightly colored, high-contrast silkscreen print of a vintage kitchen appliance, such as a retro refrigerator or oven, repeated in a tight grid pattern, capturing the timeless elegance and family-centric spirit of this historic home.The gourmet kitchen in this historic Fayetteville home is the heart of the house, where the owner continues family traditions with her famous homemade pasta and meatballs.Fayetteville Today

After years of cherished memories in her Cazenovia home, Patricia Woodcock embarked on a quest to find a new haven that would capture the same warmth and spirit. She found it in a beautiful three-bedroom colonial at 5221 Leverett Lane in Fayetteville, NY, built in 1931 by renowned local architect Charles Umbrecht. The home, set on a nearly one-acre wooded lot, exudes timeless elegance with gleaming moldings, a grand staircase, and sunlit spaces perfect for showcasing Patricia's impeccable taste in vintage décor and Stickley furniture.

Why it matters

This historic home represents the enduring appeal of New England-style Colonials designed by architects like Charles Umbrecht, which have become collector's items. The property offers ample space, modern amenities, and unique features that make it the perfect family retreat, allowing Patricia to continue her family traditions in a new setting.

The details

The 2,646-square-foot home boasts a gourmet kitchen with white cabinetry, granite counters, and high-end appliances, as well as a formal dining room, wood-paneled den, and three well-sized bedrooms including a primary suite with a walk-in closet and spa-like bath. The lower level features a family room, office nook, and workshop. Outdoor highlights include a private tennis court, fenced-in dog area, and lush landscaping on the nearly one-acre lot.

  • The home was built in 1931 by renowned local architect Charles Umbrecht.
  • An open house is scheduled for Sunday, December 21st, from 10:30 AM to 12:30 PM.

The players

Patricia Woodcock

The homeowner who is looking to continue her family traditions in a new home being built in Skaneateles.

Jonathan Woodcock

Patricia's son who described the home as a "perfect family house" with unique angles and design.

Charles Umbrecht

The renowned local architect who designed the New England-style Colonial in 1931, which has become a collector's item.

Molly Elliott

The licensed real estate salesperson with Howard Hanna Real Estate Service who is representing the property.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“It is not a cookie cutter. This home has unique angles. It was built with thought and style.”

— Jonathan Woodcock, Patricia's son

“Mom loves to be warm.”

— Jonathan Woodcock, Patricia's son

“Mom loves to decorate.”

— Jonathan Woodcock, Patricia's son

What’s next

An open house is scheduled for Sunday, December 21st, from 10:30 AM to 12:30 PM. Interested buyers can contact Realtor Molly Elliott of Howard Hanna Real Estate Service for more information.

The takeaway

This historic Fayetteville Colonial represents the enduring appeal of timeless New England-style architecture and the ability to blend modern comforts with vintage charm. The property's unique features, ample space, and private setting make it an ideal family retreat, allowing the current owner to continue her family traditions in a new setting.