Cutchogue Waterfront Retreat Hits Market for $4.25M

The private 1.44-acre property on Broadwaters Cove offers expansive water views and a private dock.

Apr. 19, 2026 at 1:51am

A high-contrast, silkscreen-style grid of a single, recognizable coastal object like a sailboat or dock ladder, rendered in a palette of bold, unnatural neon colors that transform the everyday into modern pop art.A vibrant, pop art-inspired celebration of the iconic waterfront elements that define this Cutchogue retreat's unique coastal charm.Cutchogue Today

A private waterfront retreat in Cutchogue, New York has hit the market for $4,250,000. The 1.44-acre property on Broadwaters Cove features a 2,495-square-foot home with a coastal-inspired design, capturing stunning water views from nearly every room. The home includes a wide farmhouse-style front porch, an open-concept living area, a gourmet kitchen, and four bedrooms. Outdoor amenities include a covered Ipe deck, an additional deck, a private dock with a de-icing system, and room for a pool.

Why it matters

The North Fork of Long Island has become an increasingly desirable destination for luxury waterfront properties, as homebuyers seek private retreats with direct water access and panoramic views. This listing represents a rare opportunity to own a substantial waterfront estate in the sought-after Cutchogue area, catering to those seeking a peaceful, nature-immersed lifestyle just a short distance from the Hamptons.

The details

The home features a blend of comfort and craftsmanship, with a coastal-inspired color palette, classic wainscoting, custom crown molding, ceiling fans, and oak hardwood floors throughout. The open-concept living area includes a gourmet kitchen with a center island and a peninsula with bar seating, as well as a stone fireplace-anchored living room and a dining area with picture windows framing the water. French doors open to a 442-square-foot covered Ipe deck, leading to an additional 340-square-foot deck and the backyard. The second level holds four bedrooms and two full bathrooms, including the primary en suite. The fully-insulated attic offers 'flex space' with nine-foot, 10-inch ceilings, perfect for a studio or home office.

  • The property at 1940 Mason Drive in Cutchogue, New York has just been listed for sale.

The players

Sheri Winter Parker

A real estate agent with The Corcoran Group who is listing the property.

The Corcoran Group

A leading real estate brokerage firm that is representing the sale of this Cutchogue waterfront property.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“'What makes this property so extraordinary is the profound sense of solitude you feel the moment you arrive. Everyday stress simply melts away. You feel completely immersed in nature, with water access that is truly irreplaceable. From boating in the summer to evenings by the fire in winter, it's a private retreat for all seasons.'”

— Sheri Winter Parker, Real Estate Agent

What’s next

Interested buyers will need to schedule a private showing with Sheri Winter Parker of The Corcoran Group to tour the property and submit offers.

The takeaway

This Cutchogue waterfront estate represents a rare opportunity to own a substantial private retreat with direct water access, panoramic views, and high-end finishes in one of the North Fork's most desirable enclaves. The property's combination of indoor and outdoor living spaces, as well as its proximity to the Hamptons, make it an attractive option for those seeking a peaceful, nature-immersed lifestyle.