Analyst Warns of Nightmare Scenario for Bills in 2026

Buffalo faces major offseason challenges to maintain AFC dominance.

Published on Feb. 12, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

According to a Bleacher Report analysis, the Buffalo Bills could be in trouble in 2026 if they don't address several key issues this offseason. With limited salary cap space and the need to replace departed players, the Bills will be under immense pressure to have a nearly perfect offseason through free agency and the draft to avoid falling behind their AFC East rivals, particularly the New England Patriots.

Why it matters

The Bills have been one of the NFL's top teams in recent years, but their continued success is not guaranteed. Failing to make the necessary roster moves this offseason could lead to a significant step back, which would be devastating for a team with a star quarterback in Josh Allen still in his prime.

The details

The Bills are currently over $7 million in the red against the projected 2026 salary cap, limiting their ability to be major players in free agency. This puts added pressure on general manager Brandon Beane and new head coach Joe Brady to find value free agents and nail the draft to address the team's needs, which include finding a top receiving threat for Allen and maintaining the defense led by coordinator Jim Leonhard.

  • The Bills will be expected to continue their regular season dominance and improve their playoff performance under new head coach Joe Brady in 2026.

The players

Brandon Beane

The Buffalo Bills' general manager who will be tasked with navigating the team's tight salary cap situation and assembling the roster for the 2026 season.

Joe Brady

The new head coach of the Buffalo Bills, who will be expected to build on the team's recent success and lead them to a Super Bowl appearance.

Josh Allen

The star quarterback of the Buffalo Bills, who is still in his prime and will be expected to lead the team to continued success.

James Cook

The Bills' star running back who will be a key part of the team's offensive attack in 2026.

Jim Leonhard

The Bills' defensive coordinator, who will be tasked with maintaining the team's strong defensive performance.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“The Bills have issues of their own. What the Bills don't have is a lot of resources to address those issues—the team is over $7 million in the red against the projected salary cap for 2026. The team will no doubt redo some deals to free up wiggle room, but Buffalo will be hard-pressed to be major players in free agency.”

— Gavin Davenport, Bleacher Report Analyst (Bleacher Report)

What’s next

The Bills will need to make tough decisions on contract restructures and roster moves this offseason to free up salary cap space and address their key needs, particularly on offense, in order to avoid the nightmare scenario of falling behind their AFC East rivals in 2026.

The takeaway

The Bills' continued success is not guaranteed, and they face significant challenges this offseason to maintain their status as an AFC powerhouse. Failure to make the right roster moves could lead to a steep decline, putting immense pressure on the team's leadership to get it right.