Bills Mafia House in Orchard Park Up for Sale

Owner Shane Prouty looks to shift focus to family after 14 years of hosting Bills fans

Jan. 31, 2026 at 8:15pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The iconic Bills Mafia House in Orchard Park, New York, known for its Bills-themed decor and as a popular tailgating destination for Buffalo Bills fans, is up for sale. Owner Shane Prouty purchased the small two-bedroom, one-bathroom house for $58,000 in his 20s and transformed it over the years, including adding the recognizable Bills Mafia logo on the back. Prouty is now looking to sell the property, listed for just under $700,000, as he wants to focus more on his family and travel softball with his kids.

Why it matters

The Bills Mafia House has become an iconic landmark for Bills fans, serving as a gathering place for tailgating and hosting notable figures like quarterback Josh Allen. Its sale marks the end of an era, as the property is situated near the old and new Highmark Stadiums in a rapidly developing area around the team's facilities.

The details

Prouty purchased the house in his 20s and gradually turned it into a Bills-themed destination, including adding the iconic Bills Mafia logo on the back. The house, located within walking distance of both the old and new Highmark Stadiums, is now listed for just under $700,000. Prouty says he wants to shift his focus to his family and travel softball with his kids, and he hopes the Bills Mafia house can somehow be incorporated into the new developments in the area.

  • Prouty purchased the house for $58,000 in his 20s.
  • Prouty has owned the property for 14 years.
  • The house is now listed for sale for just under $700,000.

The players

Shane Prouty

The owner of the Bills Mafia House who purchased the property in his 20s and transformed it into a Bills-themed destination over the past 14 years.

Josh Allen

The Buffalo Bills quarterback who has visited the Bills Mafia House.

Del Reid

The co-founder of the Bills Mafia fan group who gave Prouty the idea to put the Bills Mafia logo on the back of the house.

Ryan Fitzpatrick

The former Buffalo Bills quarterback who expressed interest in purchasing the Bills Mafia House after it was listed for sale.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Not many people can ever have their children say that they were able to sit in their own living room with Josh Allen at one point in time.”

— Shane Prouty, Owner of the Bills Mafia House (WKBW)

“I remember reaching out to Del [Reid] and was like, 'Hey, what if I put the Bills Mafia logo on the back of the house?' And he was like, 'crazy idea, but what the heck, why not?' And it's just been a thing kind of ever since.”

— Shane Prouty, Owner of the Bills Mafia House (WKBW)

“The opportunities are now just endless.”

— Shane Prouty, Owner of the Bills Mafia House (WKBW)

What’s next

The property has already attracted interest from former Bills quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick, who reached out to Prouty about potentially purchasing the home.

The takeaway

The sale of the iconic Bills Mafia House marks the end of an era for a beloved tailgating destination for Buffalo Bills fans, but also opens up new opportunities for the property in a rapidly developing area around the team's facilities.