Long Island Bagel Chain Owners Plan $20.8M Apartment Development

The new 58-unit complex will replace the partners' former cafe and commissary kitchen in Baldwin.

Apr. 10, 2026 at 1:29am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A high-end, photorealistic studio still life featuring a stack of freshly baked bagels, a coffee mug, and architectural blueprints, conceptually representing the redevelopment of a former small business space into new housing.A new mixed-use development in Baldwin, NY will transform a former bagel shop into much-needed housing, showcasing how local businesses can play a role in community revitalization.Baldwin Today

Two business partners behind a Long Island bagel chain are planning to transform their old cafe and commissary kitchen in Baldwin, New York into a new $20.8 million, 58-unit apartment development. The project will be supported by tax incentives.

Why it matters

As Long Island continues to face a housing shortage, this new apartment complex represents an effort by local business owners to redevelop underutilized commercial spaces into much-needed residential units. The project also highlights the role that tax incentives can play in encouraging private investment in community development.

The details

Randy Narod and Joseph Anzalone, the owners of the Long Island bagel chain, are behind the planned $20.8 million apartment development in Baldwin. The 58-unit complex will replace the partners' former cafe and commissary kitchen in the area.

  • The apartment development project was announced in April 2026.

The players

Randy Narod

One of the business partners behind a Long Island bagel chain who is planning the new $20.8 million apartment development in Baldwin.

Joseph Anzalone

One of the business partners behind a Long Island bagel chain who is planning the new $20.8 million apartment development in Baldwin.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

The takeaway

This project demonstrates how private businesses can play a role in addressing local housing needs by redeveloping their own underutilized commercial spaces. The use of tax incentives also highlights how public-private partnerships can facilitate community development.