Modern first-pick QBs rarely lead teams to Super Bowl

Experts say top draft picks often struggle to turn around struggling franchises.

Apr. 15, 2026 at 2:27am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A fractured, cubist-style painting depicting a football game broken down into sharp, overlapping geometric shapes in muted silver and black tones, representing the challenges facing a top draft pick quarterback joining a struggling NFL franchise.The Raiders' selection of a new franchise quarterback faces an uphill battle, as even top draft picks often struggle to turn around struggling NFL teams.Henderson Today

If the Las Vegas Raiders select Fernando Mendoza with the first overall pick in the upcoming NFL Draft, as is widely expected, he may struggle to immediately turn around the team's fortunes. Experts say that in the modern NFL, first-round quarterbacks drafted by struggling teams rarely go on to lead those teams to Super Bowl success, despite the high expectations placed on them.

Why it matters

The Raiders have had a difficult time finding a long-term solution at quarterback in recent years, and are hoping Mendoza can be the answer. However, history shows that even highly touted QB prospects often fail to live up to the hype when joining struggling franchises.

The details

According to analysts, the challenges facing top draft pick quarterbacks are multifaceted. Not only are they joining teams that have struggled to win, but they also often lack the supporting cast of talent around them to succeed right away. Additionally, the pressure and expectations placed on first-overall QBs can be immense, making it difficult for them to develop at a natural pace.

  • The 2026 NFL Draft is scheduled for April 24-26.

The players

Fernando Mendoza

A highly touted quarterback prospect expected to be the first overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft.

Las Vegas Raiders

An NFL franchise that has struggled to find a long-term solution at quarterback in recent years and is hoping Mendoza can turn the team around.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

The takeaway

The Raiders' selection of Mendoza with the first overall pick will be closely watched, as history suggests even the most highly touted quarterback prospects often struggle to turn around struggling franchises. Mendoza will face immense pressure and expectations, and the Raiders will need to build a strong supporting cast around him to give him the best chance at success.