New Jersey's 24 Best Places to Get Crumb Cake

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

After asking its listeners for their favorite crumb cake spots in New Jersey, a local radio station compiled a list of the 24 best places to get the classic baked good across the state. The list includes longtime bakery favorites like Mueller's Bakery in Bay Head as well as local gems like Bella's Bagels in Seaside Park, which is known for its creative crumb cake flavors beyond the traditional cinnamon.

Why it matters

Crumb cake is a beloved New Jersey tradition, with bakeries and cafes across the state offering their own unique takes on the classic treat. This list highlights the state's thriving community of small businesses and artisanal bakers who are keeping the crumb cake culture alive.

The details

The 24 best crumb cake spots in New Jersey were selected based on recommendations from over 250 comments on the radio station's social media poll. Each location was mentioned at least 3-4 times by different people, indicating they are true local favorites. The list includes both iconic bakeries that have been serving crumb cake for decades as well as newer cafes and shops that have put their own spin on the classic recipe.

• The list was compiled and published on April 5, 2026.