Giants Face Dexter Lawrence Replacement Dilemma in 2026 NFL Draft

Experts identify potential options to fill the void left by the star defensive tackle's departure.

Apr. 7, 2026 at 2:46am

A dynamic, fragmented painting depicting a Giants defensive player making a forceful tackle, with the figure broken down into sharp, intersecting geometric shapes and planes in the cubist style.The Giants face a complex puzzle in finding the right replacement for their star defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence.East Rutherford Today

The New York Giants are facing a significant challenge as they look to replace star defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence, who is expected to depart the team in the upcoming offseason. Experts have identified potential replacements the Giants could target in each day of the 2026 NFL Draft to fill the void left by Lawrence's exit.

Why it matters

Dexter Lawrence has been a cornerstone of the Giants' defense for years, and his departure will leave a major hole that the team must address. Finding the right replacement is crucial for the Giants to maintain their defensive strength and competitiveness in the NFC East.

The details

With Lawrence's contract set to expire, the Giants will need to either re-sign the Pro Bowler or identify a suitable replacement through the draft. Analysts have highlighted potential options the team could consider on each day of the 2026 NFL Draft, from early-round blue-chip prospects to later-round developmental players who could grow into the role.

  • Dexter Lawrence's contract with the Giants is set to expire after the 2025 season.
  • The 2026 NFL Draft is scheduled to take place from April 24-26.

The players

Dexter Lawrence

A Pro Bowl defensive tackle who has been a key part of the New York Giants' defense for the past several seasons.

Jaxson Dart

The Giants' starting quarterback, who is entering his second season with the team.

John Harbaugh

The Giants' head coach, who is in his first year with the team.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Dexter Lawrence is going to be a tough player to replace, but the Giants have to start planning for that eventuality now. They'll need to identify the right mix of talent and potential in this draft class to find his successor.”

— Analyst

What’s next

The Giants will need to closely evaluate their options at defensive tackle in the upcoming draft and determine the best path forward to replace Dexter Lawrence, whether that's through a high-round selection or a later-round developmental player.

The takeaway

The departure of Dexter Lawrence will be a significant challenge for the Giants, but their ability to identify and develop the right replacement through the 2026 NFL Draft will be crucial to maintaining their defensive strength and competitiveness in the NFC East.