Atlantic City's Top Lobster Mac & Cheese Dishes Revealed

From classic presentations to creative twists, these local eateries serve up the best cheesy, seafood-packed comfort food

Apr. 10, 2026 at 9:12am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A brightly colored, high-contrast silkscreen print of a single, iconic lobster mac and cheese dish repeated in a tight grid pattern, capturing the vibrant and playful essence of this comfort food favorite.These Atlantic City-area restaurants are elevating the classic lobster mac and cheese dish, blending rich, creamy cheese with the decadence of fresh seafood.Atlantic City Today

After a two-year hiatus, we're revisiting the delicious topic of lobster mac and cheese in the Atlantic City, New Jersey area. Several local restaurants have standout versions of this beloved dish, with highlights including the orecchiette pasta and generous chunks of sweet lobster at Steve & Cookies By The Bay, the elegant plating at Dock's Oyster House, and the creative takes from Betty's Seafood Shack and Dougherty's Steak House.

Why it matters

Lobster mac and cheese has become a beloved comfort food staple, blending rich, creamy cheese with the decadence of fresh lobster. As a signature dish in many shore towns, these local eateries are putting their own spin on the classic, showcasing the culinary creativity and community pride found in the Atlantic City region.

The details

Mamma Leone's Italian Restaurant in New York City is credited with first combining cheese and seafood in the 1950s, pioneering the now-popular lobster mac and cheese dish. In the Atlantic City area, several restaurants have risen to the top with their own unique takes on the classic. Steve & Cookies By The Bay in Margate is praised for its use of orecchiette pasta and generous portions of sweet lobster claw meat, while Dock's Oyster House in Atlantic City wows with its elegant plating. Other standouts include the creative presentations from Betty's Seafood Shack and Dougherty's Steak House at Resorts Casino Hotel.

  • Mamma Leone's Italian Restaurant in New York City first combined cheese and seafood in the 1950s.
  • This article revisits the topic of lobster mac and cheese in the Atlantic City area after a two-year hiatus.

The players

Steve & Cookies By The Bay

A restaurant in Margate, New Jersey known for its standout lobster mac and cheese, which features orecchiette pasta and large chunks of sweet lobster claw meat.

Dock's Oyster House

An Atlantic City restaurant that serves a visually stunning and delicious lobster mac and cheese dish.

Betty's Seafood Shack

A Margate, New Jersey restaurant that puts a creative spin on lobster mac and cheese.

Dougherty's Steak House

A restaurant located inside Resorts Casino Hotel in Atlantic City that offers a noteworthy lobster mac and cheese option.

Mamma Leone's Italian Restaurant

The New York City restaurant credited with first combining cheese and seafood in the 1950s, pioneering the lobster mac and cheese dish.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Steve and Cookie's has hands down the best lobster mac and cheese I've ever had. It has become one of the dishes that I do not order at any other restaurant because experience says they will all disappoint.”

— Kristin Hurley Baker

The takeaway

These Atlantic City-area restaurants are elevating the classic lobster mac and cheese dish, blending rich, creamy cheese with the decadence of fresh seafood and showcasing the culinary creativity found in this shore town community.