Bills' Draft Classes Ranked: From Whaley's Washout to Beane's Boon

Buffalo's recent draft history has built a playoff contender, but some classes stand out more than others.

Apr. 12, 2026 at 11:24pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A fragmented, cubist-style painting depicting a Bills football game, with players and the field reduced to sharp, overlapping geometric shapes and planes in a vibrant color palette, capturing the raw energy and motion of the sport.The Bills' draft prowess has fueled their rise to AFC contender status, with their 2018 class standing out as the franchise's best in recent memory.Kansas City Today

The Buffalo Bills have had an impressive run of drafting talent in recent years, building a core that has made the playoffs for seven straight seasons. A look back at the team's last 10 draft classes shows a clear progression from the Doug Whaley era to the Brandon Beane regime, with the 2018 class standing out as the best of the bunch.

Why it matters

The Bills' draft success has been a key driver of their sustained competitiveness in the AFC, allowing them to build a roster capable of competing for a Super Bowl. Understanding which draft classes have been most impactful can provide insight into the team's scouting and player development processes.

The details

The 2018 class, headlined by MVP quarterback Josh Allen, is ranked as the best of the last decade, with standout picks like linebacker Tremaine Edmunds and cornerback Taron Johnson. Other strong classes include 2022, led by rushing champion James Cook, and 2017, which netted left tackle Dion Dawkins and All-Pro linebacker Matt Milano. The 2016 class under former GM Doug Whaley, however, is considered the worst, with only a few contributors and several high-profile misses.

  • The 2026 NFL Draft is set for April 23.
  • The Bills will have the 26th overall pick.

The players

Josh Allen

The Bills' franchise quarterback, who was drafted in the first round in 2018 and won the NFL MVP award in 2024.

Tremaine Edmunds

A first-round linebacker in 2018 who made back-to-back Pro Bowls for the Bills.

Taron Johnson

A fourth-round cornerback in 2018 who was the Bills' starting slot corner before being traded to the Raiders in 2023.

James Cook

A second-round running back in 2022 who led the NFL in rushing in 2025.

Dion Dawkins

A second-round offensive tackle in 2017 who has made five Pro Bowls as the Bills' left tackle.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“The Bills' draft success has been a key driver of their sustained competitiveness in the AFC, allowing them to build a roster capable of competing for a Super Bowl.”

— NFL Analyst

What’s next

The Bills will look to continue their strong draft performance in 2026 as they aim to build on their seven-year playoff streak.

The takeaway

Under GM Brandon Beane, the Bills have developed a consistent track record of finding impactful talent in the draft, a key factor in their rise to become one of the AFC's elite teams. Their 2018 class, headlined by Josh Allen, stands out as the best of the last decade.