Melvindale Police Lieutenant Fired Amid Assault Charges and Surging Lawsuit Costs

City terminates officer Matthew Furman after multiple misconduct allegations and insurance woes

Published on Feb. 13, 2026

Melvindale, Michigan has fired a high-ranking police officer, Lt. Matthew Furman, following a series of misconduct allegations that led to assault charges and costly lawsuits against the city. The termination comes as the city faces the loss of its liability insurance coverage due to the growing legal issues surrounding the police department.

Why it matters

The firing of Lt. Furman and the city's insurance troubles highlight the growing challenges Melvindale faces in maintaining public trust and financial stability amid a history of police-related legal problems. The situation could expose taxpayers to additional financial risk if the city is unable to secure new liability coverage.

The details

Lt. Matthew Furman was terminated from his position following a series of incidents that led to assault charges and notable lawsuits against the city. This includes a $1 million lawsuit settlement involving Furman's use of a taser. Police Chief Chris Egan cited Furman's conduct within the force as the reason for his dismissal. Compounding Melvindale's troubles is the termination of the city's liability insurance, which experts say could leave taxpayers vulnerable to additional financial risk if new coverage cannot be secured.

  • On February 11, 2026, Police Chief Chris Egan issued a letter to Furman indicating his dismissal was "for cause".
  • The city's liability insurance premium has increased from $510,000 to $633,000 in the previous year.

The players

Matthew Furman

A former Melvindale police lieutenant who was fired amid multiple misconduct allegations and lawsuits against the city.

Chris Egan

The Melvindale Police Chief who issued the letter terminating Furman's employment.

Nicole Shkira

The Mayor of Melvindale who confirmed Furman's firing, emphasizing the choice made under the department's refreshed leadership.

Lawrence Coogan

The Melvindale City Attorney who voiced concerns about the city facing "financial ruin" due to the insurance and legal issues.

Chad Hayse

A former Melvindale police chief who filed a wrongful termination lawsuit against the city.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“We were informed through local media that Mr. Furman had been terminated. This was with no notice or hearing as required. The union is filing a grievance.”

— Furman's lawyer (FOX 2 Detroit)

“The city received a clear warning of financial strain. City Attorney Lawrence Coogan voiced concerns about "financial ruin," signaling the depth of the municipality's predicament.”

— Lawrence Coogan, Melvindale City Attorney (WXYZ-TV)

What’s next

The city's insurance broker advised Melvindale to demonstrate a commitment to reforming its police force as a measure to attract new insurers, with Furman's termination potentially being a part of such efforts.

The takeaway

Melvindale's termination of a high-ranking police officer and its insurance woes highlight the broader challenges the city faces in rebuilding public trust and financial stability amid a history of police-related legal issues. The situation underscores the need for comprehensive police reform and risk management strategies to protect taxpayers from further liabilities.