Millions of Seniors Lose Medicare Advantage Coverage Across Rural U.S.

Insurers retreat from plans in states like Idaho, New Hampshire and Vermont, forcing elderly to scramble for alternatives.

Apr. 2, 2026 at 10:21pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An extreme close-up X-ray photograph revealing the delicate bone structure and veins of an elderly person's hand, conceptually representing the fragility and vulnerability of seniors losing their healthcare coverage.As Medicare Advantage plans retreat from rural areas, the healthcare security of millions of seniors hangs in the balance.Portland Today

Nearly 3 million seniors nationwide were forced off their Medicare Advantage plans in 2026 as insurance companies sharply retreated from the privatized Medicare option, especially in rural areas from Idaho to New England. The sudden loss of coverage has left many elderly patients like 70-year-old New Hampshire resident Anthony J. Petchkis struggling to afford the higher costs of traditional Medicare.

Why it matters

The exodus of Medicare Advantage plans from rural communities highlights the risks for seniors who rely on the privatized plans, which are under no obligation to offer coverage year-over-year. When profit margins are threatened, insurers can suddenly withdraw, leaving elderly patients with limited options and higher out-of-pocket costs.

The details

Insurers like UnitedHealthcare cited rising healthcare costs and reduced government reimbursements as reasons for exiting counties with over 600,000 Medicare Advantage beneficiaries. In New Hampshire's Carroll County, the nonprofit carrier WellSense pulled its most popular plan, leaving only one option that is not appropriate for most seniors. Across Vermont, about 35,000 people lost their Medicare Advantage coverage entirely.

  • In 2026, nearly 3 million seniors nationwide were forced off their Medicare Advantage plans.
  • In New Hampshire, about 77,000 seniors lost their Medicare Advantage coverage this year.
  • In Vermont, around 35,000 people lost their Medicare Advantage plans.

The players

Anthony J. Petchkis

A 70-year-old landscape artist living in the mountains of New Hampshire who lost his Medicare Advantage coverage this year.

UnitedHealthcare

The nation's largest Medicare Advantage carrier, which said it would exit counties where it had 600,000 beneficiaries, citing a desire to reinvigorate profit.

WellSense

A nonprofit carrier based in Massachusetts that pulled its most popular Medicare Advantage plan out of New Hampshire's Carroll County.

Mark Mindell

A 78-year-old retired fitness instructor in Vermont who lost his Medicare Advantage coverage when his plan, Vermont Blue Advantage, withdrew from the state.

Dean Cameron

The head of the Idaho Department of Insurance who accused UnitedHealthcare of making it difficult for consumers to sign up for Medicare Advantage plans in the state.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“How am I going to pay all these things going into the future? Now I seem okay, but six months or a year from now, something really catastrophic could happen.”

— Anthony J. Petchkis

“An additional $200 a month is not something I can do. I called and said I'm not coming. I can't afford 20% of what this is going to cost.”

— Mark Mindell, Retired Plumber

“They shouldn't be able to do these inappropriate actions, which are really harmful to our most vulnerable senior citizens.”

— Dean Cameron, Head of Idaho Department of Insurance

What’s next

The judge in the case will decide on Tuesday whether or not to allow Walker Reed Quinn out on bail.

The takeaway

This case highlights growing concerns in the community about repeat offenders released on bail, raising questions about bail reform, public safety on SF streets, and if any special laws to govern autonomous vehicles in residential and commercial areas.