Red Sox Ace Garrett Crochet Struggles to Regain Dominant Form

The once-stellar pitcher faces a puzzling slump, leaving the team and fans searching for answers

Apr. 20, 2026 at 4:13am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A fragmented, geometric painting depicting a baseball pitcher's motion, with sharp planes of navy, green, and brown hues, conceptually representing the mental challenges faced by the Red Sox ace.A cubist interpretation of a Red Sox pitcher's delivery, reflecting the mental complexities of Garrett Crochet's slump.Boston Today

Boston Red Sox star pitcher Garrett Crochet, who led the team to a remarkable 24-9 record in his starts last season, is now facing a concerning slump. His recent performances have seen his ERA skyrocket to 7.88, leaving the team and fans alike perplexed. Crochet himself acknowledges the stark contrast in his play, pinpointing falling behind in counts as the primary issue.

Why it matters

Crochet's struggles highlight the crucial role that mental resilience and sports psychology play in an athlete's performance. Even the best players can succumb to slumps, and the Red Sox must now rally around their ace to help him overcome the mental blockades that are hindering his success.

The details

In a recent game against the Tigers, Crochet showcased moments of brilliance but also conceded five earned runs and seven hits in just five innings. This inconsistency has left the team searching for answers. Crochet recognizes that the problem is more mental than physical, as he struggles to maintain focus and adapt to in-game situations.

  • Crochet led the Red Sox to a 24-9 record in his starts during the 2025 season.
  • Crochet's current ERA has skyrocketed to 7.88 in the 2026 season.

The players

Garrett Crochet

A talented left-handed pitcher for the Boston Red Sox who is currently facing a puzzling slump after a dominant 2025 season.

Boston Red Sox

The professional baseball team that Garrett Crochet plays for, currently grappling with his struggles on the mound.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“I'm just falling behind in counts, and that's really hurting me. The four-pitch walk to Gleyber Torres was a big turning point.”

— Garrett Crochet

What’s next

The Red Sox must now work closely with Crochet to help him regain his mental focus and overcome the psychological barriers that are hindering his performance. The team's success in the 2026 season will depend on their ability to support their ace and help him rediscover the dominant form that made him a standout in 2025.

The takeaway

Crochet's struggles serve as a reminder that even the best athletes can face mental hurdles that impact their performance. The Red Sox must now prioritize sports psychology and provide the necessary support to help their star pitcher regain his confidence and return to his dominant form.