Kentucky Senate Pauses Judge's Impeachment Inquiry Amid Conduct Review

The Senate Impeachment Committee unanimously voted to suspend proceedings against a Lexington judge, pending a judicial board review.

Apr. 15, 2026 at 1:56pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A serene, cinematic painting of an empty courtroom with warm sunlight streaming through the windows, creating a contemplative and somber atmosphere that evokes the political dispute at the heart of this story.The Kentucky Senate's decision to pause the impeachment inquiry against a Lexington judge reflects the complex constitutional tensions between the legislative and judicial branches.Frankfort Today

The Kentucky Senate Impeachment Committee has unanimously voted to suspend impeachment proceedings against Fayette Circuit Judge Julie Muth Goodman, pending the outcome of a review by the state's Judicial Conduct Commission. The move comes after the state Supreme Court ruled that the initial impeachment process violated the separation of powers between the legislative and judicial branches.

Why it matters

The impeachment inquiry against Judge Goodman has highlighted the ongoing tensions between the legislative and judicial branches in Kentucky. The Senate's decision to pause the proceedings and refer the matter to the Judicial Conduct Commission reflects an effort to navigate these complex constitutional issues and ensure a fair and impartial review of the allegations against the judge.

The details

The Senate Impeachment Committee, led by Republican Sen. Brandon Storm, filed a resolution to pause the impeachment proceedings and refer the matter to the Judicial Conduct Commission, which has the power to discipline judges. The committee's action was driven by the Senate's constitutional duties and a desire for fairness to the defendant, according to Storm. The Supreme Court had previously ruled that the initial impeachment process violated the separation of powers, and the Judicial Conduct Commission is now reviewing the allegations against Goodman.

  • The House forwarded articles of impeachment against Goodman to the Senate last month.
  • The Kentucky Supreme Court ruled that the impeachment had violated the separation of powers and ordered it halted.
  • The Senate Impeachment Committee unanimously voted to suspend the impeachment proceedings on April 15, 2026.

The players

Brandon Storm

Republican senator and chair of the Senate Impeachment Committee.

Julie Muth Goodman

Fayette Circuit Judge who was the subject of the impeachment inquiry.

Debra Hembree Lambert

Chief Justice of the Kentucky Supreme Court, who wrote the majority opinion that halted the impeachment proceedings.

Cassie Chambers Armstrong

Democratic Senate Whip who voted to stay the impeachment proceedings.

Robert Stivers

Republican Senate President who stated the Senate's commitment to upholding the state constitution.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“The Senate's action 'cannot be construed as an acquittal or as the Senate relinquishing any rights or duties under the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Kentucky.'”

— Brandon Storm, Republican senator and chair of the Senate Impeachment Committee

“It is unfortunate that the existence of that was not known to the House when the inquiry early in the process was requested.”

— Brandon Storm, Republican senator and chair of the Senate Impeachment Committee

“The Supreme Court clearly ruled that further action would be unconstitutional, and my preference would be that this body clearly state its intent to comply with that order.”

— Cassie Chambers Armstrong, Democratic Senate Whip

“Above all, the Senate remains committed to upholding the integrity of the Constitution of Kentucky and preserving the balance among our three independent, co-equal branches of government.”

— Robert Stivers, Republican Senate President

What’s next

The Senate is expected to review the committee's action to pause the impeachment proceedings against Judge Goodman later on April 15, 2026, which is the final day of the legislative session. If the Judicial Conduct Commission clears Goodman of wrongdoing, the Senate may choose to revisit the impeachment inquiry in a future legislative session.

The takeaway

This case highlights the complex constitutional issues surrounding the separation of powers between the legislative and judicial branches in Kentucky. The Senate's decision to pause the impeachment proceedings and refer the matter to the Judicial Conduct Commission reflects an effort to navigate these challenges and ensure a fair and impartial review of the allegations against the judge.