Gem County Commissioners Delay Decision on Controversial Merrill's Pit Gravel Project

Neighbors voice concerns over dust, property values, and traffic impacts in two-night public hearing

Apr. 8, 2026 at 1:11pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Tensions remain high in Emmett, Idaho as Gem County Commissioners held a two-night public hearing on the proposed 393-acre Merrill's Pit gravel project, but ultimately delayed making a final decision. Neighbors voiced frustrations over long-term health impacts, property value loss, and the project's impact on the community, while the developer argued the project is essential for local growth.

Why it matters

The debate over the Merrill's Pit gravel project highlights the ongoing tensions between residential development and industrial operations in growing communities. Neighbors are concerned about the project's potential to negatively impact their quality of life and property values, while the developer argues the local aggregate is essential for the community's infrastructure needs.

The details

Nearly 130 people attended the first night of the public hearing on Monday, and more than 90 returned on Tuesday to voice support or opposition to the proposed gravel project. Neighbors raised concerns over dust, property value loss, and the impact of increased truck traffic, especially near Emmett High School and along Star Lane. The current landowner, David Little, testified in support of the project, while some neighbors criticized nearby homebuilders and realtors for not disclosing the potential gravel pit when they sold properties. Granite Excavation, the developer, argued the project is essential for local growth and addressed concerns over noise, traffic, and dewatering. After the two-night hearing, the commissioners did not make a final decision and will hold a deliberation on May 26.

  • The public hearing was held over two nights, on Monday and Tuesday.
  • The commissioners will hold a deliberation on May 26 at 6 p.m. to make a final decision.

The players

Gem County Commissioners

The local government officials responsible for reviewing and deciding on the Merrill's Pit gravel project proposal.

David Little

The current owner of the proposed Merrill's Pit land, who testified in support of the project.

Granite Excavation

The developer proposing the 393-acre Merrill's Pit gravel project, which they argue is essential for local growth and infrastructure needs.

Mark McCord

An Emmett neighbor who voiced concerns about the project's dust and health impacts.

Tamara Peccorini

An Emmett neighbor who lives adjacent to the proposed site and criticized nearby homebuilders and realtors for not disclosing the potential gravel pit.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“I can assure you that my house stays covered in dust all the time… dust that I don't need in my lungs or on my property.”

— Mark McCord, Emmett Neighbor

“The value of the home is based off the buyer so ask me… I'm the buyer!”

— Emmett Neighbor

“The mining operation reduces values into a homeowner that has placed their entire savings into the home... it is significant.”

— Emmett Neighbor

“First, I want to be very clear, this is not an issue of preventing local jobs. We are not against local jobs by any means or gravel pits. I'm a construction worker myself. It is the location of these gravel pits that is a problem.”

— David Dutra, Emmett Neighbor

“The reality is the opposite. Residential development is moving towards existing gravel pits.”

— Josh Davis, President, Granite Excavation

What’s next

The Gem County Commissioners will hold a deliberation on May 26 at 6 p.m. at the Gem County Annex, where they are expected to make a final decision on the Merrill's Pit gravel project proposal.

The takeaway

The debate over the Merrill's Pit gravel project highlights the ongoing challenges communities face in balancing residential growth and industrial operations. While the developer argues the local aggregate is essential, neighbors are concerned about the project's potential negative impacts on their quality of life and property values. The commissioners' final decision will have significant implications for the future development and character of the Emmett area.