Tybee Island Debates Historic District Proposal

Residents divided over plan to preserve island's historic character

Published on Feb. 11, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A proposed historic district designation on Tybee Island, Georgia has sparked debate among homeowners. The city's Historic Preservation Commission is seeking to create the Fort Screven and North Campbell Neighborhood Local Historic District, which would require homeowners to obtain approval before making exterior changes to their properties. While some residents support the plan to protect Tybee Island's heritage, others argue it would unfairly limit their property rights, especially for homes they say have no historical significance.

Why it matters

The debate over the proposed historic district highlights the ongoing tension between historic preservation and private property rights. As coastal communities like Tybee Island grapple with development pressures and the need to maintain their unique character, finding the right balance is crucial.

The details

The proposed historic district would cover the Fort Screven and North Campbell neighborhoods on Tybee Island. If approved, homeowners within the district would be required to obtain approval from the city's Historic Preservation Commission before making any exterior changes to their properties. This would involve submitting official documentation for review. City officials say the measure is aimed at preserving Tybee Island's historic character, but some residents argue it doesn't make sense to include newer homes that lack historical significance.

  • The Tybee Island City Council will hold the first reading of the historic district ordinance during their meeting on Thursday, February 13, 2026.

The players

Wayne Lesher

A Pennsylvania resident who owns a home on Tybee Island that was built around 1999 or 2000, and argues his property has no historical significance.

Ben Goggins

A resident who lives within Tybee Island's existing National Historic District and supports the proposed historic district, stating he is not concerned about added restrictions.

Brian West

The mayor of Tybee Island, who acknowledges the complexity of the issue and the need to balance historic preservation with private property rights.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Why you're just going to throw a blanket over this is ridiculous. My house was built in either '99 or 2000. It has no historical significance.”

— Wayne Lesher (wtoc.com)

“I'm not at all concerned by anything that I've heard that it would restrict my property owner's rights to change my paint color or do an external modification.”

— Ben Goggins (wtoc.com)

“We do have homes in this area that don't necessarily have historic value, but we want to preserve the ones that do. So, it's going to be a difficult thing for council to juggle.”

— Brian West, Mayor (wtoc.com)

What’s next

Tybee Island City Council will hold the first reading of the historic district ordinance during their meeting on Thursday, February 13, 2026.

The takeaway

The debate over the proposed historic district on Tybee Island highlights the ongoing challenge of balancing historic preservation with private property rights. As coastal communities grapple with development pressures, finding the right approach to maintain their unique character while respecting individual property owners' rights is crucial.