Perfectionists Struggle More When Boss' Expectations Exceed Their Own

New research finds employees' perfectionism is more problematic when it doesn't align with supervisors' high standards

Apr. 9, 2026 at 3:32am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A high-end, photorealistic studio still-life featuring a sleek metal pen, glass paperweight, and minimalist digital clock arranged on a clean, monochromatic background. The dramatic lighting and shadows symbolize the tension between an employee's personal drive for perfection and their supervisor's high standards.A study finds that when employees' personal standards of perfectionism don't align with their boss' high expectations, it can lead to greater workplace stress and burnout.Warrington Today

A study from the University of Florida Warrington College of Business found that whether perfectionism helps or harms employees depends largely on whether their personal standards align with their supervisors' expectations. When employees' standards exceed their boss' expectations, they tend to experience more role ambiguity, burnout, and lower job satisfaction.

Why it matters

Perfectionism is a common issue, with 93% of employees struggling with it at work. This research provides insights into how organizations can better support perfectionistic employees by clarifying expectations and ensuring alignment between workers and their managers.

The details

The study analyzed data from over 350 employees and 100 supervisors. It found that when employees' personal standards of perfectionism are aligned with their supervisors' high expectations, they tend to have less role ambiguity and better work outcomes like higher performance, lower burnout, and greater job satisfaction. However, the most problematic scenario is when supervisors expect higher levels of perfectionism than employees expect from themselves, leading to greater uncertainty about roles and worse work results.

  • The research was published in April 2026 in the journal Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes.

The players

University of Florida Warrington College of Business

The research institution that conducted the study on the impact of employee-supervisor perfectionism (in)congruence.

Brian Swider

Beth Ayers McCague Family Professor at the University of Florida Warrington College of Business and lead author of the study.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Problems between employees and their supervisors are more likely to arise when these expectations don't match.”

— Brian Swider, Beth Ayers McCague Family Professor

“If you're an employee who struggles with perfectionism at work, our findings suggest that understanding your supervisor's expectations may be just as important as managing your own tendencies towards perfectionism.”

— Brian Swider, Beth Ayers McCague Family Professor

What’s next

The researchers recommend that organizations should consider how employees and supervisors are paired, as mismatched expectations can increase stress, reduce job satisfaction and ultimately impact performance. They also suggest that employers help their employees by clarifying expectations through regular feedback and performance conversations to reduce role ambiguity.

The takeaway

This study highlights the importance of aligning employee and supervisor expectations around perfectionism in the workplace. By fostering clear communication and shared understanding of performance standards, organizations can help perfectionistic employees thrive and avoid the negative impacts of mismatched expectations.