Florida Midwife Accused of Causing Permanent Injury to Newborn

State alleges midwife used excessive force, failed safety protocols during home birth

Apr. 17, 2026 at 8:50pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An extreme close-up of a newborn's injured arm, the skin discolored and swollen, conceptually illustrating the severe nerve damage caused by alleged midwife negligence.A devastating nerve injury sustained by an infant during a home birth highlights the need for greater oversight of midwifery practices.St. Petersburg Today

The Florida Department of Health has accused licensed midwife Sizzly Maria Auer of unprofessional conduct and multiple violations stemming from a 2021 home birth that left an infant with lifelong disabilities. The state alleges Auer used excessive force, failed to employ recognized emergency techniques, and did not properly document the delivery, resulting in a newborn suffering severe nerve damage.

Why it matters

This case highlights concerns about oversight and accountability in the home birth industry, as well as the potential risks when midwives do not follow established safety protocols. It also raises questions about licensing requirements and insurance coverage for midwives in Florida.

The details

According to the complaint, Auer was overseeing the home birth of Victoria Vasser's child, Dylan Davis, when the labor became complicated by shoulder dystocia. Rather than using recognized techniques, the state alleges Auer 'failed to employ one or more recognized maneuvers' and instead 'pulled continuously and forcibly' on the infant's head and neck, causing severe nerve damage. Investigators also claim Auer instructed the mother to push during the emergency, a move that can worsen the situation.

  • The incident occurred during a home birth in November 2021.
  • Auer has been a licensed midwife in Florida since 2010.

The players

Sizzly Maria Auer

A licensed midwife in Florida since 2010 who is accused of using excessive force and failing to follow safety protocols during a home birth that left an infant permanently injured.

Victoria Vasser

The mother of the infant, Dylan Davis, who was injured during the home birth overseen by Auer.

Dylan Davis

The newborn who suffered severe nerve damage to his arm as a result of the home birth incident.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

The state is seeking disciplinary action against Auer that could include revocation or suspension of her license, fines, probation, or other penalties. Auer has the right to contest the allegations and request a hearing.

The takeaway

This case highlights the importance of midwives following established safety protocols and the need for stronger oversight and accountability in the home birth industry to protect the wellbeing of mothers and infants.