Experts Refute Claims of Nationwide Christian Revival in America

Scholars say anecdotal evidence doesn't reflect broader religious trends, as Trump supporters aim to oversimplify the narrative for political gain.

Apr. 5, 2026 at 2:13pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Christian conservatives, including supporters of former President Donald Trump, have claimed there is a Christian revival occurring in America, but experts say the truth is more complicated. While some anecdotal evidence suggests a pause in the decline of religious affiliation, scholars caution this does not necessarily indicate a true nationwide revival. Pew Research has found no clear evidence of a broad religious resurgence, particularly among younger generations. Experts argue that politically, it benefits Republicans allied with the Christian right to portray America as an inherently Christian country, despite the separation of church and state being a foundational American principle.

Why it matters

The debate over the state of religion in America has significant political implications, as the Christian right has become closely aligned with the Republican party. Misrepresenting religious trends could be used to justify policies that blur the line between church and state, undermining a core tenet of American democracy.

The details

The New York Times' Lauren Jackson reported that while some anecdotal evidence suggests a pause in the decline of religious affiliation in the U.S., experts have urged caution about interpreting this as a true nationwide revival. David Campbell, a political scientist at the University of Notre Dame, said 'For us to call this a true revival, we would need to see a level of conversion that we have never seen in the history of the United States.' Pew Research also refuted claims of a religious resurgence, particularly among younger generations.

  • The New York Times article was published on April 5, 2026.

The players

David Campbell

A political scientist at the University of Notre Dame who researches secularization.

Lauren Jackson

A reporter for The New York Times who wrote the article on the debate over the state of religion in America.

Steve Schmidt

A former Republican who advised President George W. Bush, and who has criticized the Trump administration's use of Christianity to push its policy goals.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“'These stories are a very small drop in a very large ocean, whose currents have for decades been taking people away from religion. For us to call this a true revival, we would need to see a level of conversion that we have never seen in the history of the United States.'”

— David Campbell, Political Scientist, University of Notre Dame

“'The separation of church and state is foundational to American civilization. In fact, on the list of the greatest American inventions, the two at the top — competing for gold and silver — are the peaceful transition of power and the separation of church and state. These are brilliant ideas, the greatest in all of history.'”

— Steve Schmidt, Former Republican Advisor

The takeaway

This debate highlights the political motivations behind claims of a nationwide Christian revival in America, as the Christian right has become closely aligned with the Republican party. Experts caution that anecdotal evidence does not reflect broader religious trends, and warn that misrepresenting the state of religion could be used to undermine the separation of church and state, a foundational American principle.