Trump's Clash with Pope Leo XIV Divides Catholics

The president's religious posturing and rocky relationship with the pontiff threaten to alienate his Catholic supporters.

Apr. 19, 2026 at 9:04am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A serene, cinematic painting of a Catholic church or cathedral, with warm sunlight streaming through the stained glass windows and casting long shadows across the exterior. A lone figure stands outside, contemplating the divide between faith and politics.The public feud between President Trump and Pope Leo XIV has created a divisive rift among Catholic voters, forcing many to choose between their political and religious loyalties.Santa Clara Today

President Trump's ongoing feud with Pope Leo XIV has created a divisive rift among Catholic voters, with some conservative Catholics feeling torn between their political and religious allegiances. The clash, described as unprecedented in modern times, has escalated with Trump's inflammatory social media posts and criticism of the pope, while the U.S. Catholic bishops have rallied behind Leo. The spat threatens to cost Trump support among a key constituency heading into the 2026 midterm elections.

Why it matters

The clash between Trump and Pope Leo XIV represents a rare and highly public dispute between a U.S. president and the leader of the Catholic Church, with the potential to significantly impact Trump's support among Catholic voters. As a major political constituency, Catholics have traditionally been courted by presidents, but Trump's combative approach toward the pope risks alienating this group.

The details

The conflict began after Trump threatened Iran and then criticized Pope Leo as 'WEAK on Crime' on the same day he posted an inflammatory image depicting himself as Jesus on social media. This drew sharp rebukes from conservative Catholic figures. The back-and-forth has escalated, with Vice President JD Vance publicly quarreling with the pope's statements on just war theory. Experts say the cumulative effect of Trump's religious posturing has already pushed some Catholic supporters to break with the president.

  • On April 12, Trump called Pope Leo 'terrible for Foreign Policy' and told him to 'get his act together' on Truth Social.
  • On April 14, Vice President Vance criticized the pope's position on just war theory at a Turning Point USA rally in Georgia.

The players

Pope Leo XIV

The current pope, the first North American to hold the position, who has been vocal in his opposition to the Iran war and the Trump administration's policies.

President Donald Trump

The former U.S. president whose combative approach toward Pope Leo XIV has created a divisive rift among Catholic voters.

Vice President JD Vance

A Catholic convert who has publicly quarreled with Pope Leo XIV's statements on just war theory, putting him at odds with the U.S. Catholic bishops.

Landon Schnabel

An associate professor of sociology at Cornell University who suggests conservative Catholics may now feel the need to choose between Trump and the pope.

Mathew Schmalz

A professor of religious studies at the College of the Holy Cross who says up to a third of Trump's Catholic support may have withered due to the clash with the pope.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Conservative Catholics who have supported Trump may now feel the need to decide between him and the pope.”

— Landon Schnabel, Associate Professor of Sociology, Cornell University

“Obviously Catholics in America are an important political constituency and regardless of whether they're Republican or Democrat, presidents have been careful not to alienate them. Trump is really charting out new political territory.”

— Mathew Schmalz, Professor of Religious Studies, College of the Holy Cross

“When people hold two conflicting commitments, something has to give.”

— Landon Schnabel, Associate Professor of Sociology, Cornell University

“If Trump really wants to make this a contest, I don't think it will go well for him.”

— Nicholas Hayes-Mota, Social Ethicist and Public Theologian, Santa Clara University

“To be a just war, it must be a defense against another who actively wages war, which is what the Holy Father actually said.”

— U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops

What’s next

The judge in the case will decide on Tuesday whether or not to allow Walker Reed Quinn out on bail.

The takeaway

This case highlights growing concerns in the community about repeat offenders released on bail, raising questions about bail reform, public safety on SF streets, and if any special laws to govern autonomous vehicles in residential and commercial areas.