Giants Fans Frustrated by Lack of Offseason Spending

Team's revenue and financial strength raise questions about unwillingness to invest in roster

Published on Feb. 21, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

In a scathing column, sports writer Dieter Kurtenbach criticizes the San Francisco Giants for their lack of significant offseason moves, despite the team's strong financial position. Kurtenbach argues that the Giants' front office, led by Buster Posey, is "gaslighting" fans by framing any requests for roster improvements as unrealistic, when the team has the resources to spend more aggressively. He points to the team's high revenue, low debt levels, and strong profitability as evidence that the Giants should be investing more in their on-field product to compete with rivals like the Los Angeles Dodgers.

Why it matters

The Giants' offseason spending, or lack thereof, has become a major point of contention among the team's fanbase. As one of the wealthiest franchises in baseball, the Giants' reluctance to invest in the roster raises questions about the team's commitment to winning and whether they are prioritizing profits over performance.

The details

Kurtenbach criticizes the Giants' offseason moves, which he describes as a "buffet of mid-tier, minimal-market, lets-take-a-low-stakes-gamble free agents." He argues that the team should have been more aggressive in addressing key needs, such as signing a closer or adding depth to the starting rotation. Kurtenbach also points to the Dodgers' superior roster as evidence that the Giants are falling behind their rivals.

  • Buster Posey's interview on KNBR last week sparked Kurtenbach's criticism.
  • The Giants' 2026 offseason moves were the focus of Kurtenbach's analysis.

The players

Buster Posey

A former Giants player who is now an executive with the team.

Farhan Zaidi

The former Giants general manager, known for his focus on roster depth and bottom-of-the-roster moves.

Tony Vitello

The Giants' new manager, whose recent press conference was the subject of Kurtenbach's initial criticism.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Look, I get it, from a fan's perspective, they want us to go out and sign every marquee free agent. That sounds great in theory, but that's not reality.”

— Buster Posey (KNBR)

What’s next

The Giants' front office will likely face continued scrutiny from fans and media over their offseason spending decisions, especially if the team struggles on the field in the 2026 season.

The takeaway

The Giants' reluctance to invest in their roster, despite their strong financial position, has become a major point of contention among the team's fanbase. This situation highlights the tension between a team's desire to maintain profitability and its obligation to field a competitive team that can contend for championships.