MLB Analyst Thinks Padres May Trade Star Player Tatis Jr.

Payroll concerns could force San Diego to move their franchise cornerstone.

Apr. 15, 2026 at 6:54pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

MLB analyst Harold Reynolds believes the San Diego Padres may need to consider trading star player Fernando Tatis Jr. in the near future due to the team's high payroll and multiple players signed to long-term, expensive contracts. Reynolds suggests Tatis' recent shift to second base could be a 'showcase' of his versatility to other teams, as the Padres look to free up salary space, potentially by moving their young superstar.

Why it matters

The Padres have one of the highest payrolls in baseball, with several players locked into lucrative long-term deals. Parting ways with Tatis, the team's most valuable asset, could provide financial flexibility but would be a major blow to the franchise's future. This potential trade scenario highlights the challenges small-market teams face in keeping their star players while managing payroll constraints.

The details

The Padres have won 6 of their last 8 games to start the 2026 season, but analyst Harold Reynolds believes the team may need to consider trading 24-year-old superstar Fernando Tatis Jr. due to the club's high $255.9 million payroll. Reynolds suggests Tatis' recent shift to second base could be a 'showcase' of his versatility to other teams, as the Padres look to free up salary space. Tatis, along with Manny Machado, Xander Bogaerts and Jackson Merrill, are all signed to long-term, high-dollar contracts, making Tatis the most valuable trade chip for the Padres to potentially move.

  • The Padres have a $255.9 million payroll for the 2026 season.
  • Tatis has struggled to start the 2026 season, hitting .242 with no home runs and a .619 OPS.

The players

Fernando Tatis Jr.

The 24-year-old superstar shortstop for the San Diego Padres, signed to a long-term, high-dollar contract.

Manny Machado

The veteran third baseman for the San Diego Padres, also signed to a long-term, high-dollar contract.

Xander Bogaerts

The veteran shortstop for the San Diego Padres, signed to a long-term, high-dollar contract.

Jackson Merrill

A promising young player for the San Diego Padres, yet to fully recapture his rookie season form.

Harold Reynolds

An MLB analyst for the MLB Network.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“I think this is a showcase. The Padres payroll — I know they're up there battling the Dodgers every year, we say it over and over and over — I'm sorry, they gotta do something. They can't carry this payroll. The Dodgers can, [the Padres] can't carry this. Somebody's gotta go.”

— Harold Reynolds, MLB Analyst

“So, who of those guys do I want? I want Fernando Tatis.”

— Harold Reynolds, MLB Analyst

What’s next

The Padres will need to make tough decisions regarding their payroll and roster in the coming months, with the potential sale of the team also looming. Moving Tatis could provide financial flexibility but would be a major blow to the franchise's future.

The takeaway

This situation highlights the challenges small-market teams face in keeping their star players while managing payroll constraints. The Padres' high-priced roster and potential need to trade Tatis Jr. could have significant implications for the team's long-term competitiveness.