California Man Charged in $34K Lego Swap Scheme

Suspect allegedly replaced Lego pieces with dried pasta to get refunds at Target stores

Apr. 17, 2026 at 10:50pm

An extreme close-up photograph of a pile of dried pasta against a pitch-black background, lit by a harsh, direct camera flash, conceptually representing the fraudulent swap scheme in a stark, gritty, investigative aesthetic.Dried pasta substituted for Lego pieces in an alleged retail theft scheme highlights the creative lengths some criminals will go to defraud major retailers.Paramount Today

Police have arrested a 28-year-old California man, Jarrelle Augustine, on suspicion of grand theft for allegedly buying Lego sets at Target, removing some of the figures, swapping in bags of dried pasta, and then returning the boxes for refunds. Authorities say Augustine is linked to around 70 such incidents at Target stores across the country, resulting in losses totaling roughly $34,000.

Why it matters

This case highlights the growing problem of retail theft and fraud, which has become an increasing concern for major retailers like Target. The alleged scheme, which involved swapping out expensive Lego sets for cheap pasta, demonstrates the creative and deceptive tactics some criminals will use to steal from businesses.

The details

According to police, Augustine would purchase Lego sets from Target, remove some of the Lego figures, and replace them with bags of dried pasta. He would then return the boxes, claiming they were incomplete, and receive refunds. Authorities say they were able to identify Augustine through surveillance footage and that the affected stores include locations in Irvine, Westminster, and Costa Mesa, as well as other sites outside of Orange County.

  • On April 16, 2026, Irvine police announced Augustine's arrest.

The players

Jarrelle Augustine

A 28-year-old man from Paramount, California, who was arrested on suspicion of grand theft for allegedly swapping Lego pieces with dried pasta to get refunds at Target stores.

Irvine Police Department

The law enforcement agency that announced Augustine's arrest and investigated the alleged Lego swap scheme.

Target

The retail chain that reported around 70 incidents of the alleged Lego swap scheme, resulting in losses totaling roughly $34,000.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Authorities noted the sound of shaking pasta can resemble loose Lego pieces.”

— Officer Ziggy Azarcon, Irvine Police Department

What’s next

Augustine is currently in custody at the Orange County Jail, and authorities are investigating whether he may have committed similar thefts at other retail locations.

The takeaway

This case highlights the growing problem of retail theft and the creative tactics some criminals will use to defraud businesses. It serves as a reminder for retailers to be vigilant in their security measures and for consumers to be wary of any suspicious product returns or exchanges.