Palo Alto Debates Closing Suicide-Prone Railroad Crossing

Community divided over proposal to shut down Churchill Avenue crossing near high school

Apr. 16, 2026 at 7:55am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A minimalist design in the style of Keith Haring where the outline of a railroad crossing signal is defined entirely by glowing, vibrant neon lines against a deep, dark background, emphasizing the urgent need for action to address this public health crisis.As Palo Alto grapples with a spate of student suicides at a local railroad crossing, the community is divided over a proposal to close the dangerous site.Palo Alto Today

After four Palo Alto High School students died by suicide using railroad crossings in the last two years, the city council is considering a controversial proposal to close the Churchill Avenue crossing near the school. The community is divided, with some advocating to save lives and others concerned about the severe traffic and safety impacts of the closure.

Why it matters

Palo Alto is grappling with a public health crisis of youth suicide, and the city is exploring drastic measures like closing a major railroad crossing to try to prevent further tragedies. This debate highlights the difficult tradeoffs communities face when trying to balance public safety, transportation needs, and mental health support.

The details

The proposal to close the Churchill Avenue railroad crossing near Palo Alto High School was brought forward after four students from the school died by suicide using the crossing in the last two years. Closing the crossing would divert around 8,000 cars and 700 students to other roads daily, causing severe traffic impacts. There are also concerns about slowing down police and fire services. Before the crossing could be closed, the city would need to take steps to make surrounding streets safer for pedestrians and cyclists, which could take years and cost a lot of money.

  • In the last two years, four Palo Alto High School students died by suicide using railroad crossings.
  • The city council debated the proposal to close the Churchill Avenue crossing on April 16, 2026.
  • The city council will revisit the issue again on May 11, 2026.

The players

Mare Lucas

An advocate for youth mental health after losing her 18-year-old son to suicide in 2017.

Nadia Niak

A member of the Expanded Community Advisory Panel who says there is not enough time or money to make the necessary street safety improvements before closing the crossing.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“If we could just save one life, that's all we're asking.”

— Mare Lucas, Mental Health Advocate

“There's not enough time to do it. There's not the money to do it. Even the mitigations they can do in the quickest amount of time would take years and cost a lot of money.”

— Nadia Niak, Member, Expanded Community Advisory Panel

What’s next

The city council will revisit the proposal to close the Churchill Avenue railroad crossing on May 11, 2026.

The takeaway

This debate in Palo Alto highlights the difficult tradeoffs communities face when trying to address public health crises like youth suicide. While closing a dangerous railroad crossing could save lives, the severe traffic and safety impacts make it a complex and controversial solution that requires careful consideration of all the implications.